Open Archives Meet Open Peer Review?

Workshop on The Open Archives Initiative and Peer Review Journals CERN, Geneva, March 2001 <http://documents.cern.ch/OAi/>

3/26/01

View web version

PowerPoint originals, 2.79M [OpenPeerReview.ppt]
Acrobat handout, 2.3M [OpenPeerReview.pdf]

Table of Contents

Open ArchivesMeetOpen Peer Review?

Peer review dimensions

Conventional peer review

A ‘native internet’ peer review model

JIME’s peer review lifecycle

eJournals: Levels 1-6Lancaster, F. W. (1985). The Paperless Society Revisited. American Libraries, 16, (8), 553-555

Author links from text to discussion

linking from one review discussion to a relevant document

Document-related news updated in the discussion space

JIME email alert to new review comment

Review process initiated with introductory email to authors and reviewers

JIME changes…

JIME changes… (cont/d)

Conversational Open Peer Review?

D3E Publisher’s Toolkit (Publisher’s Tab)

D3E Publisher’s Toolkit (Article Tab)

Server-side: D3E -Phorum architecture

D3E meets an ePrint server

‘Ubiquitous D3E’...discuss any web documente.g. pass it an OAI document URL + specify thread titles around which to focus comments and discussion

Demo: generating a peer review discussion space for an arXiv document

Adding a comment on an arXiv document

Email confirmation of new review discussion site

Knowledge Media InstitutePhD on OAI+Peer Review – deadline 31st Maykmi.open.ac.uk/studentshipsJournal of Interactive Media in Educationwww-jime.open.ac.ukDigital Document Discourse Environmentd3e.open.ac.uk(contact me to receive D3E release news)Scholarly Ontologies Projectkmi.open.ac.uk/projects/scholonto

Author: Simon Buckingham Shum & Gary Li

Email: sbs@acm.org

Home Page: http://kmi.open.ac.uk/sbs/

Other information:
Knowledge Media Institute Open University, UK

ÿ