E-LIS, Eprints in Library and Information Science Homepage E-LIS, Eprints in Library and Information Science
   home   |   about   |   search   |   browse   |   register   |   registered users area   |   help   |   FAQ   |   JITA   

The impact of the Internet on Reference services in Higher Education libraries in South Africa

Darries, Fatima (2002) The impact of the Internet on Reference services in Higher Education libraries in South Africa. Masters, Dept. of Information and Library Science, University of Cape Town (South Africa).

Full text available as:
PDF - Requires Adobe Acrobat Reader or other PDF viewer.

View statistics for this eprint

Abstract

Internet access has become an indicator of a country’s socio-economic status in the Information Society. Libraries of higher education institutions support the parent institutions’ objective to produce graduates able to function in this society. Consequently, the Web, the most popular part of the Internet, has become ubiquitous in reference services. This study investigates the impact of the Internet on reference services by exploring the following areas: user Internet access and training in the library, use and integration of the Internet as an information tool in reference services and the Internet training and knowledge of reference librarians.

An electronic survey was done using the Web and e-mail to distribute the questionnaire. The questionnaire was divided into six sections, and consisted of multi-choice answers with an open-ended question at the end of each section inviting further comments. The target population was the heads of reference services at large libraries and the directors at smaller libraries of the 36 higher education institutions in South Africa. Their e-mail addresses were obtained from the library or parent institutions’ Web sites. A total of 90 potential respondents were e-mailed and 26 responded, representing 19 institutions and yielding a low response rate of 29%. Low response rates are however, typical of electronic surveys. A total of eight reference librarians at two institutions in the Western Cape were interviewed, representing both a historically disadvantaged institution (HDI) and a historically advantaged institution (HAI), and a technikon and university library. The interviews were structured and consisted of mostly open-ended questions. The interviews lasted about an hour and were tape-recorded.

The results showed that all responding libraries have Internet access and all but one provided access to their users. On average, users have had Internet access for three and a half years. User Internet training tended to be on a one-to-one basis at the point-of-use. On average, reference librarians have had Internet access for five years. The majority of librarians have attended formal Internet training programmes. However, the librarians interviewed considered these to be introductory and gained the skills and knowledge by actual use and from colleagues. Librarians reported that the reference process took longer, that user search behaviour had changed and expectations had increased. While the majority of libraries had Web sites, only a small number of librarians had individual pages that they updated and maintained. The majority of libraries provided electronic reference via e-mail and the library Web site, but these are characterised by low usage. Finally, libraries tended to offer both end-user and intermediary searching to online databases. The study concluded, amongst others: that libraries lacked adequate computer facilities and consequently cannot provide optimal Internet access to students, and that librarians have integrated the Internet as an information tool but that libraries have not yet taken full advantage of what the Internet offers. The study recommends: that the bandwidth and number of student computer facilities be increased in libraries and that this problem be addressed at national government level, that libraries develop electronic reference as a core service, and that librarians increase their Internet and online instruction efforts by using e-mail, Web tutorials and virtual classrooms to reach more students.

Keywords:world wide web, www, Web, Reference librarians, academic librarians, higher education, Internet
Subjects:L. Information technology and library technology. > LC. Internet, including WWW.
ID Code:6627
Deposited By:Darries, Fatima
Deposited On:06 July 2006
All fields:Show all fields

Abdoulaye, K. & Majid, S. 2000. Use of the Internet for reference services in Malaysian libraries. Online information review. 24(5):381-388.

Abels, E.G. & Liebscher, P. 1994. A new challenge for intermediary-client communication: the electronic network. Reference librarian. 41/42:185-196.

Abels, E.G. 1996. The e-mail reference interview. RQ. 35(3):345-348.

About VRD. 2002. The virtual reference desk. [Online]. Available: http://www.vrd.org/about.html [2002, May 28].

Ardis, S.B. 1998. Creating Internet-based tutorials. Information outlook. 2(10):17-20. [Online]. Available: http://www.sla.org/pubs/serial/io/1998/oct98/ardis.html [1999, June 18].

Arp, L. 1995. Reflecting on reflecting: views on teaching and the Internet. RQ. 34(4):453-7. [Online]. Available: Infotrac at http://infotrac.london.galegroup.com [2001, November 12].

Babu, B.R. & O’Brien, A. 2000. Web OPAC interfaces: an overview. The electronic library. 18(3):316-327.

Bates, M.E. 1997. The Internet: part of a professional searcher’s toolkit. Online. 21(1):47-52.

Bergman, M.K. 2000. The deep Web: surfacing hidden value. [Online]. Available: http://www.BrightPlanet.com [2001, October 27].

Bordeianu, S. Carter, C.E. & Dennis, N. K. 2000. Delivering electronic resources with Web OPACs and other Web-based tools: needs of reference librarians. Reference services review. 28(2):111-118.

Boyer, J. 2001. Virtual reference at the NCSU libraries: the first one hundred days. Information technology & libraries. 20(3):122-129. [Online]. Available: http://www.lita.org/ital/2003_boyer.html [2002, May 21].

Braun, L.W. 2000. Learning from the inside. Library journal. Net connect supplement. 125(10):28-30.

Bristow, A. 1992. Academic reference services over electronic mail. College & research libraries news. 10:631-632.

Bristow, A. & Buechley, M. 1995. Reference services over e-mail: an update. College & research libraries news. 7:459-460.

Busha, E.H. & Harter, S.P. 1980. Research methods in librarianship: techniques and interpretation. New York: Academic Press.

Cailliau, R. 1995. A little history of the World Wide Web from 1945 to 1995. [Online]. Available: http://www.w3.org/History.html [2000, October 3].

Chamberlain, E. 1997. BCK2SKOL lesson 2: History of the Net. [Online]. Available: http://www.web.csd.sc.edu/bckskol/fall/lesson2.html [1997, June 14].

Cook, C., Heath, F. & Thompson, R.L. 2000. A meta-analysis of response rates in Web- or Internet-based surveys. Educational and psychological measurement. 60(6):821-836.

Cook, K. 1994. The incredible expanding OPAC. Library journal. 119 (21):69.

Diamond, W. & Pease, B. 2001. Digital reference: a case study of question types in an academic library. Reference services review. 29(3):210-218.

Dilevko, J. 2001. An ideological analysis of digital reference service models. Library trends. 50(2):218-244.

Dodson, S. 2001. The race for a new Internet. Guardian unlimited. [Online]. Available: http://www.gaurdian.co.uk/Archive/Article/0,4273,4294049,00.html [2001, November 19].

Eichler, L. & Halperin, M. 2000. LivePerson: keeping reference alive and clicking. Econtent. 23(3):63. [Online]. Available: Academic Search Elite, EbscoHost at http://search.epnet.com [2002, March 26].

European Commission (E.C.) 1995. White paper on growth, competitiveness and employment. [Online]. http://www.ispo.cec.be/infosoc/whitepaper/top.html [1997, March 12].

Evans, B. 1999. The authors of academic library home pages: their identity, training and dissemination of Web construction skills. Internet research. 9(4):309-319.

Factiva, a Dow Jones & Reuters Company. [Pamphlet]. 2000. [S.l.]: Dow Jones Reuters Interactive.

Faries, C. 1994. Reference librarians in the information age: learning from the past to control the future. In Reference services planning in the 90’s. Edited by G.Z. Eckwright & L.M. Keenan. New York: Haworth. 9-28.

Farmer, L.S.J. 1999. Building power by sharing what you have. Library Talk. 12(1):33-43.

Feizabadi, S. 1996. History of the World Wide Web. In WWW beyond the basics. [Online]. Available: http://ei.cs.vt.edu/~wwwbtb/book/chap1/web_hist.html [2000, October 3].

Fichter, D. 1999. Intranets: librarians, dive in. Online. 23(3):107-108.

Fingerman, S. 1999. Internet2 and the Next Generation Internet: two for the future. Information outlook. 3(11):44-45.

Fonseca, T. & King, M. 2000. Incorporating Internet into traditional library instruction. Computers in libraries. 20(2):38-52. [Online]. Available: Infotrac at http://infotrac.london.galegroup.com [2001, November 12].

Francoeur, S. 2001. An analytical survey of chat reference services. Reference services review. 29(3):189-203.

Freivalds, D.I. & Carson, S.M. 1991. The role of microcomputers in the evolution of the OPAC. Library software review. 10(2):110-114. [Online]. Available: Academic Search Elite, EbscoHost at http://search.epnet.com [2000 May 29].

Garman, N. 1999. The ultimate, original search engine. Online. 23(3):6.

Geyser, E.P. 1992. Human factors in the interaction process between man and the user friendly information retrieval system. South African journal of library and information science. 60 (3):167-173.

Gomez Borah, E. 1992. Beyond navigation: librarians as architects of information tools. Research strategies. 10(Summer):138-142.

Gray, S.M. 2000. Virtual reference services: directions and agendas. Reference & user services quarterly. 39(4):365-375.

Hale, M.L. 1991. Getting ready for tomorrow - or today. Reference services review. 19(Spring):74-76.

Harmsen, B. 2000. Adding value to Web-OPACs. Electronic library. 18(2):109-113.

Hathorn, C. 1997. The librarian is dead, long live the librarian. Pretext. [Online]. Available : http://www.pretext.com/oct97/features/story4.html [1998, September 9].

Herholdt, A. De V. 1987. Online bibliographic information retrieval in South Africa. [M.Bibl. thesis]. University of the Witwatersrand. (Unpublished).

Howards, E.H. & Jankowski, T.A. 1986. Reference services via electronic mail. Bulletin of the Medical Library Association. 74(1):41-44.

Hruska, M. 1995. Remote Internet serials in the OPAC? Serial review. 21(4):68. [Online]. Available: Academic Search Elite, EbscoHost at http://search.epnet.com [2000, May 29].

Janes, J., Carter, D. & Memmott, P. 1999. Digital reference services in academic libraries. Reference & user services quarterly. 39(2):145-150.

Jascó, P. 1997. CD-ROM. In International encyclopedia of information and library science. Edited by J. Feather & P. Sturges. London: Routledge. 51-53.

Johnston, A. & Nicolle, J. 2000. Personalizing the library: the portal development project at the University of Canterbury Library. Conference of the Library and Information Association of New Zealand and Aotearoa: Exceeding expectation. 15-18 October, Christchurch, New Zealand. [Online]. Available: http://www.conference.co.za/LAINZA2000/PaperJohnston.pdf [2002, June 8].

Kalin, S. & Wright, C. 1994. Internexus: a partnership for Internet instruction. In Librarians on the Internet: impact on reference services. Edited by R. Kinder. New York: Haworth. 197-209.

Keenan, S. 1996. Concise dictionary of library and information science. London: Bowker Saur.

Klopper, S.M. 1999. Finding a new search rhythm. Online. 23(5):38-41. [Online]. Available: Academic Search Elite, EbscoHost at http://search.epnet.com [2000, June 17].

Kyrillidou, M. 2000. Perspectives on …research library trends: ARL statistics. Journal of academic librarianship. 26(6):427-437. [Online]. Available: Academic Search Elite, EbscoHost at http://search.epnet.com [2001, July 7].

Leiner, B.M. et al. 1998. A brief history of the Internet. [Online]. Available: http://www.isoc.org/internet/history/brief.html [1998, September 14].

Maloney, J. 1986. Online information services. In ALA World encyclopedia of Library and Information Science. 2nd ed. Chicago: ALA.

Mayfield, K. 2000. Ask a librarian, not Jeeves. Wired news. [Online]. Available: http://www.wired.com/news/culture/0,1294,40308,00.html [2002, May 25].

McDermott, I.E. 2000. Internet instruction: spreading the Web. Searcher. 8(7):72. [Online]. Available Academic Search Premier, EbscoHost at http://search.epnet.com [2002, March 26].

Mickey, B. 1999. A web search trifecta. Online. 23(3):79-82.

Mood, T.A. 1994. Of sundials and digital watches: a further step toward the new paradigm of reference. Reference services review. 22(Fall):27-95.

Morville, P.S. & Wickhorst, S.J. 1996. Building subject-specific guides to Internet resources. Internet research: electronic networking applications and policy. 6(4):27-32.

Murphy, C. 1998. The online catalog on the way to the millennium. Multimedia schools. 5(3):20-24. [Online]. Available: MasterFILE PREMIER, EbscoHost at http://search.epnet.com [2000, May 29].

Nelson, M.L. 2001. Integrated access to library resources. Online. 25(2):48-53.

Newton, R. et al. 1998. Using the Internet to support lifelong learning: the role of the librarian. The challenge to be relevant in the 21st century: 19th IATUL conference. 1-5 June, University of Pretoria, South Africa [Online]. Available : http://educate.lib.chalmers.se/IATUL/proceedcontents/pretpap/newton.html [1998, September 14].

Nicholas, D & Fenton, D. 1997. The Internet and the changing information environment. Managing information. 4(1/2):29-32.

Nicholls, P. 1998. Even the holy grail cannot accommodate multimedia. [Editorial: CD/DVD Librarian] Computers in libraries. 18 (9):54.

Nicholls, P. 1999. Are we throwing out the baby with the bath water? [Editorial: CD/DVD Librarian] Computers in libraries. 19(8):69.

Notess, G.R. 1998. The year databases moved to the web. Database magazine. 21(6):56-58. Available: Academic Search Elite, EbscoHost at http://search.epnet.com [2000, June 17].

Notess, G.R. 1999a. Minimal intranets for libraries. Online. 23(1):74-76.

Notess, G.R. 1999b. Rising relevance in search engines. Online. 23(3):84-86.

Oder, N. 2001. The shape of e-reference. Library journal. 126(2):46-50.

Ojala, M. 1999. The end of online as we know it. Database magazine. 22(6):6. [Online]. Available: Academic Search Elite, EbscoHost at http://search.epnet.com [2000, June 17].

Parsons, A.M. 2001. Digital reference: how libraries can compete with Aska services. Digital Library Federation newsletter. 2(1). [Online]. Available at http://www.diglib.org/pubs/news02_01/RefBenchmark.htm [2002, March 26].

Pask, J.M. & Snow, C.E. Undergraduate instruction and the Internet. Library trends. 44(2):306-317. [Online]. Available: Infotrac at http://infotrac.london.galegroup.com [2001, November 12].

Peterson, E. & Lowry, C.B. 1995. Management decisions – beyond the OPAC. Journal of academic librarianship. 21(1):43-45. [Online]. Available: Academic Search Elite, EbscoHost at http://search.epnet.com [2000, May 29].

Pollitz, J.H. 1994. Internet resources: opportunity knocks at our door. In Librarians on the Internet: impact on reference services. Edited by R. Kinder. New York: Haworth. 127-137.

Powell, C.A. & Bradigan, P.S. 2001. E-mail reference services: characteristics and effects on overall reference services at an academic health sciences library. Reference & user services quarterly. 41(2):170-178.

Powell, R.R. 1991. Basic research methods for librarians. 2nd ed. Norwood, N.J.: Ablex.

Pretorius, C. 1996. The costs of CD-ROM technology: can we afford it? Innovation. 13(December):28-30.

Price, G. 2001. The almost invisible Web: potential solutions. [Online]. Available: http://websearch.about.com/library/weekly/aa091800b.htm [2001, October 27].

Rasodi, M.A.M. 2000. An assessment of the use of electronic sources in reference librarianship. [M.Bibl. thesis]. University of South Africa. (Incomplete).

Rettig, J.R. 1986. Reference and information services. In ALA world encyclopedia of library and information services. 2nd ed. Chicago: American Library Association.

Ritch, A. 1991. Back to the future: from desk set to desklessness? Reference services review. 19(Spring):74-76.

Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology University. 1999. IT strategies for learners. [Online]. Available: http://www.its.tmit.edu.au/corporate/it_strategic_ plan/strategies_for_learners.html [2002, May 28].

Saeed, H. et al. 2000. Internet use in university libraries of Pakistan. Online information review. 24(2):154-160.

Schaefer, D.R. & Dillman, D.A. 1998. Development of a standard e-mail methodology: results of an experiment. Public opinion quarterly. 62(3):378-397.

Schneider, K.G. 2000. My patron wrote me a letter: the joy of e-mail reference. American libraries. 31(1):96.

Shannon, D.M. & Bradshaw, C.C. 2002. A comparison of response rate, response time, and costs of mail and electronic surveys. Journal of experimental education. 70(2):179-192.

Sheehan, K.B. & McMillan, S.J. 1999. Response variation in e-mail surveys: an exploration. Journal of advertising research. 39(4):45-54.

Sherman, C. 1999. The future of web search. Online. 23(3):54-61.

Silva, M. & Cartwright, G.F. 1994. The Internet and the reference librarians: a question of leadership. In Librarians on the Internet: impact on reference services. Edited by R. Kinder. New York: Haworth. 159-172.

Sloan, B. 1998. Electronic reference services: some suggested guidelines. Reference & user services quarterly. 38(1):77-81. [Online]. Available: http://www.lis.uiuc.edu/b~sloan/guide.html [2000, October 25].

Sloan, B. 2001. Ready for reference: academic libraries offer live Web-based reference: evaluating system use. [Online]. Available: http://alexia.lis.uiiuc.edu/~b-sloan/r4r.final.htm [2002, May 21].

South Africa. Department of Arts, Culture, Science and Technology. 1996. The Information Society and the developing world: a South African approach. Information Society and Development Conference (ISAD). 13-15May, Gallagher Estate, Midrand. [Online]. Available: http://www.csir.co.za/isad.html [1997, March 26].

South Africa. Department of Education & Department of Communication. 2002. Strategy for information and communication technology in education. [Online]. Available: http://education.pwv.gov.za/teli2/ICT_strategy.htm [2002, June 8].

South Africa. Department of Education. 1999. Department of Education/European Union higher education libraries programme. [Online]. Available: http://education.pwv.gov.za/EU/default.htm [2002, May 2].

South Africa. Department of Education. 2001. The restructuring of the higher education system in South Africa: report of the National Working Group to the Minister Education: issues and recommendations. [Online]. Available: http://education.pwv.gov.za/Policies_and_Reports/2001_Report/RestructuringHE.htm [2002, June 8].

Stormont, S. 2001. Going where the users are: live digital reference. Information technology & libraries. 20(3):129-149.

Stover, M. 2000. Reference librarians and the Internet: a qualitative study. Reference services review. 28(1):39-46.

Sturges, P. 1997. Subject librarian. In International encyclopedia of information and library science. Edited by J. Feather & P. Sturges. London: Routledge.

Sullivan, D. 1999. Crawling under the hood: an update on search engine technology. Online. 23(3):30-36.

Swanepoel, M. 1989. Die beskikbaarheid van elektroniese brondatabasisse by Suid Afrikaanse universiteite en technikons. [M.Bibl. thesis]. University of Pretoria. (Unpublished).

Tenopir, C. 1989. What’s happening with CD-ROM, part 1. Library journal. 114(2):50-51.

Tenopir, C. 1998. Online databases: Will online vendors survive. Library journal. 123(2):35-36. [Online]. Available: Academic Search Elite, EbscoHost at http://search.epnet.com [2000, June 17].

Tenopir, C. 1999. Electronic reference and reference librarians: a look through the 1990’s. Reference services review. 27(3):276-279.

Tenopir, C. 2000. Getting what you pay for. Library journal. 125(2):34-35. [Online]. Available: Academic Search Elite, EbscoHost at http://search.epnet.com [2001, June 17].

Tenopir, C. 2001. Virtual reference in the real world. Library journal. 126(12):38.

Tenopir, C. & Barry, J. 1999. Data dealers forging links. Library journal. 124(9):40-48.

Tenopir, C & Ennis, L. 1998a. The digital reference world of academic libraries. Online. 22(4). [Online]. Available: http://wwwonlineinc.com/onlinemag/OL1998/tenopir7.html [2000, October 13].

Tenopir, C. & Ennis, L. 1998b. The impact of digital reference on reference librarians. Online. 22(6). [Online]. Available: http://wwwonlineinc.com/onlinemag/OL1998/tenopir11.html [2000, October 13].

Tenopir, C. & Ennis, L. A. 2001. Reference services in the new millennium. Online. 25(4);41-45.

Tenopir, C. & Neufang, R. 1992a. Electronic reference options: how they stack up in research libraries. Online. 16(2):22-29.

Tenopir, C. & Neufang, R. 1992b. The impact of electronic reference on reference librarians. Online. 16(3):54-60.

Tenopir, C. & Neufang, R. 1995a. Electronic reference tracking the changes. Online. 19(4). [Online]. Available: http://wwwonlineinc.com/onlinemag/OL1995/JulOL95/tenopir-neufang.html [1998, September 26].

Tenopir, C. & Neufang, R. 1995b. Internet use and training in university libraries. 16th National Online Meeting Proceedings., 2-4 May, New York . Edited by M.E. Williams. Medford, N.J.: Learned Information. 387-393.

Thomsen, E. 1999. Rethinking reference: the reference librarians’ practical guide for surviving constant change. New York: Neal - Schuman.

Tseng, G. 1997. Online and CD-ROM databases. In International encyclopedia of information and library science. Edited by J. Feather & P. Sturges. London: Routledge. 328-330.

Union of Students in Ireland. 2001. One computer for every 33 students as universities fails to reach target. [Online]. Available: http://www.usi.ie/news/computers24sept.htm [2002, March 28].

Van Brakel, P.A. 1993. Implications of networking CD-ROM databases in a research environment. South African journal of library and information science. 61(1):28-33

Van Brakel, P.A. 1997. Online database vendors: will they transform to pull technology? South African journal of library and information science. 65(4):234-242.

Viggiano, R. & Ault, M. 2001. Online library instruction for online students. Information technology and libraries. 20(3):135-138.

Vishwanatham, R., Wilkins, W. & Jevec, T. 1997. The Internet as a medium for online instruction. College & research libraries. 58(8):434-444.

Weaver, A.E. 2000. Personal Web pages as professional activities: an exploratory study. Reference services review. 28(2):171-177.

Weaver, M. 1996 The globalization of online services: the online searcher as facilitator. Managing information. 3(11):32-33.

What is CDRS? 2002. Collaborative Digital Reference Service. [Online]. Available: http://www.loc.gov/rr/digiref/about.html [2002, May 28].

Whatis.com: the IT-specific encyclopedia: a techtarget.com community. 1999. [Online]. Available: http:///www.whatis.com [2000, June 17].

White, H.S. 1995 Information intermediation: a fancy name for reference work. Library Journal. 120(5):44-45.

Wiese, F. O. & Borgendale, M. 1986. EARS: electronic access to reference services. Bulletin of the Medical Library Association. 74(1):300-304.

World Wide Web Consortium. 2002. HyperText Markup Language (HTML) Home page. [Online]. Available: http://www.w3.org/MarkUp [2002, July 5].

Archive Staff Only: edit this record