Osvrt na odnos iscrpnosti informacije i njene pouzdanosti : primjer - zaštita okoliša i promjene klime

Pravdić, Velimir (2007) Osvrt na odnos iscrpnosti informacije i njene pouzdanosti : primjer - zaštita okoliša i promjene klime. Vjesnik bibliotekara Hrvatske 50(1-2):pp. 43-50.

Full text available as: PDF - Requires Adobe Acrobat Reader or other PDF viewer.

Abstract

[Croatian abstract]

Problem odnosa iscrpnosti informacije i njene pouzdanosti razmotren je na primjeru upotrebe informacija iz zaštite okoliša, točnije, o promjeni globalne klime. Ova je prirodoznanstvena tema multidisciplinarna: granično je područje s tehnologijom, ekonomijom i sociologijom. Iscrpnost informacije nije upitna: suvremeni pretraživački programi daju iscrpne i vrlo brojne podatke. Upitni su kriteriji selekcije pouzdanosti informacije. U navedenom primjeru, pouzdanost informacije teško je provjerljiva jer globalne promjene klime nisu dostupne klasičnoj eksperimentalnoj provjeri, osnovici prirodoznanstvenih disciplina. U članku se raspravlja o ideologizaciji polazišta, upotrebi one informacije koja potvrđuje preduvjerenja autora. Tako se stvaraju osnove za donošenje dalekosežnih gospodarskih odluka, koje su uvjetovane većinskim, politiziranim mišljenjima znanstvenika i, konačno, pristupom problemu, koji uključuje vjerovanje, a to je područje religije, a ne znanosti.

[English abstract]

The relationship between comprehensiveness of information and its reliability is reviewed on the example of its use in the discipline of environmental protection, more precisely, in the case of global climate change. This scientific topic is multidisciplinary in character, bordering on technology, economy and sociology. Computerized information search programs yield comprehensive and numerous data. The problem is in the selection criteria applied to assess the reliability of overwhelming numbers of information units. In the discussed example, the reliability of information is difficult to verify, because global climate change is not accessible to experimental verification, a crux of the scientific method. The paper discusses the topic of ideological bias in the selection of information that corroborates the preconceived opinions of a paper’s author. Far-reaching economic decisions are made in this manner, reflecting the majority beliefs of scientists, a position that belongs to the realm of religion, rather than to science.

Keywords:	globalna promjena klime, iscrpnost informacija, pouzdanost informacija, pretraživanje informacija; global climate change, comprehensiveness of information, reliability of information, information retrieval
Subjects:	B. Information use and sociology of information. > BA. Use and impact of information.
ID Code:	13398
Deposited By:	Pavelic, Damir
Deposited On:	12 May 2008
Alternative Locations:	http://www.hkdrustvo.hr/datoteke/286/vbh/God.50(2007),br.1-2
All fields:	Show all fields

Hürter, Tobias. Warum AIDS gefärlicher ist als der Klimawandel. // Spiegel Online. Dostupno na: http://www.spiegel.de/wissenschaft/mensch/0,1518,396395,00.html

Linden, Eugene. The winds of change : climate, weather and the destruction of civilizations. New York : Simon and Schuster, 2006.

Lomborg, Björn. The skeptical environmentalist : measuring the real state of the world. Cambridge ; New York : Cambridge University Press, 2001.

Mosnews.com. News Archive : Russian scientists forecast global cooling in 6-9 years. Dostupno na: htpp://www.mosnews.com/news/2006/08/25

Oreskes, Naomi. The scientific consensus on climate change. // Science 306, 5702(2004), 1686.

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency : Region 7. Quality assurance questions and answers. Dostupno na: http://www.epa.gov/Region7/qa/qafaq.htm

Walker, Bill. Global cooling : fear the ice. Dostupno na: http://www.lewrockwell.com/walker

Archive Staff Only: edit this record