The relationship between ILL/document supply and journal subscriptions

Bernardini, Elena and Mangiaracina, Silvana The relationship between ILL/document supply and journal subscriptions. Interlending & Document Supply, 2010, vol. 39, n. 1. [Journal article (Unpaginated)]

[thumbnail of Bernardini-Mangiaracina_pre-print_ILDS_2011.pdf]
Preview
PDF
Bernardini-Mangiaracina_pre-print_ILDS_2011.pdf

Download (440kB) | Preview

English abstract

Purpose: The purpose of this article is to provide insights into the relationship between ILL/ document supply and journal subscriptions and to assess recent trends in the ILL service. Design/methodology/Approach: This survey is based on data from the ILL service conducted over the five year period 2005-2009 through the Italian NILDE (Network for Inter-Library Document Exchange) network. Findings: This article bears out important previous findings that ILL is not used as a surrogate for journal subscriptions. This is supported by the analysis of a broad number of titles and over a wide time-range. On the contrary, analysis of data transactions, particularly of the most requested journals, can bring about positive effects on new title acquisitions and negotiations with publishers. This paper also shows, at least for Italy, an overall growth and vitality of ILL, in spite of the widespread availability of e-journals acquired through consortia purchasing. Originality/Value: An insight into the relationship between ILL and journal subscriptions in Italy, a country where few studies have been carried out, and none at all for such a large number of libraries and transactions.

Item type: Journal article (Unpaginated)
Keywords: interlibrary loan, resource sharing, document supply, electronic journals, consortia purchasing, Italy
Subjects: J. Technical services in libraries, archives, museum. > JB. Serials management.
J. Technical services in libraries, archives, museum. > JJ. Document delivery.
J. Technical services in libraries, archives, museum. > JK. Interlibrary loans.
Depositing user: Silvana Mangiaracina
Date deposited: 07 Feb 2011
Last modified: 02 Oct 2014 12:18
URI: http://hdl.handle.net/10760/15339

References

N. I. S. O., ANSI. (2006), The OpenURL Framework for context-sensitive services : an American national standard, National Information Standards Organization, Bethesda, Md.

Bador, P., Romdhane, M. B. and Lafouge, T. (2003), “European pharmaceutical journals: Relationship between demand and indexation - The example of the main French document supplier”, Canadian Journal of Information and Library Science, Vol 27 No 2, pp 33-55.

Baveye, P. C. (2010), “Sticker Shock and Looming Tsunami : The high cost of academic serials in perspective”, Journal of Scholarly Publishing, Vol 41 No 2, pp 191-215.

Echeverria, M. and Barredo, P. (2005), “Online journals: their impact on document delivery”, Interlending & Document Supply, Vol 33 No3, pp 145-149.

Filippucci, G., Bernardini, E., Mangiaracina, S., Brunetti, F., De Carolis, E., Domina, P., Fasano, M., Fuschini, E., Grazioli, M., Magno, R., Olimpieri, Salamone, P., Stabene, S. (2009), “Strategies and alliances into action to improve national collaboration”, in Proceedings of the 11th Interlending and Document Supply IFLA Conference, Strategic Alliances and Partnerships in Interlending and Document Supply, 20-22 October 2009, Hannover, Germany. Available at:

http://www.ilds2009.eu/fileadmin/user_upload/Full_text/Elena_Bernardini-1.pdf (accessed 23rd July 2010)

Gillet, J. (2008), “Sharing resources, networking and document delivery: the INIST experience”, Interlending & Document Supply, Vol 36 No 4, pp 196-202.

Glover, S. W., Addison, J., Gleghorn, C., Aalai, E. and Annis, S. (2009), “Interlending and document supply trends in NHS North West health libraries 2003/2004 to 2006/2007”, Health Information and Libraries Journal, Vol 26 No1, pp 32-38.

Goodier, R. and Dean, E. (2004), “Changing patterns in interlibrary loan and document supply”, Interlending & Document Supply, Vol 32 No4, pp 206-214.

ICSTI. (1996), “A comparative study of access to journals through subscriptions and document delivery”.

Jackson, M. E. (2004), “Will electronic journals eliminate the need for ILL?”, Interlending & Document Supply, Vol 32 No3, pp 192-193.

Kidd, T. (2003), “Does electronic journal access affect document delivery requests? Some data from Glasgow University Library”, Interlending & Document Supply, Vol 31 No 4, pp 264-269.

Koyama, K., Sato, Y., Tutiya, S. and Takeuchi, H. (2009), “Transformation of the ILL Services Among the Japanese University Libraries in Digital Era: The Results of the Comprehensive Analysis of NACSIS-ILL Transaction Records from 1994 to 2007”, in Proceedings of the 11th Interlending and Document Supply IFLA Conference, Strategic Alliances and Partnerships in Interlending and Document Supply, 20-22 October 2009, Hannover,

Germany. Available at: http://www.ilds2009.eu/fileadmin/user_upload/Full_text/ilds_kenjikoyama20091021_paper.pdf (accessed on 4th October 2010)

Lacroix, E. M. (1994), “Interlibrary loan in U.S. health sciences libraries: journal article use”, Bulletin of the Medical Library Association, Vol 82 No4, pp 363-8.

Lacroix, E. M. and Collins, M. E. (2007), “Interlibrary loan in US and Canadian health sciences libraries 2005: update on journal article use”, Journal of the Medical Library Association : Vol 95 No2, pp 189-94.

Line, M. B., Guerrero, E. M., Jackson, M. E., Mark, N., Sene, H. and Waaijers, L. (2002), “The future of interlibrary loan and document supply: views and comments”, Interlending & Document Supply, Vol 30 No2, pp 60-65.

Mangiaracina, S. (2002), “NILDE: a Document Delivery System Supporting Document Exchange via the Internet”, Library Hi Tech News, Vol 19 No8, pp 39-41.

Mangiaracina S., Beghelli E. (2004), “Il Servizio Document Delivery della Biblioteca di Area del CNR di Bologna. Report 2002-2003”, Technical report, 2004 available at http://puma.isti.cnr.it/dfdownload.php?ident=/cnr.bibo/2004-TR-001 (accessed on 4th October 2010)

Mangiaracina, S., Zaetta, M., De Matteis, D., Tugnoli, A., Beghelli, E. and Tenaglia, G. (2008), “NILDE: developing a new generation tool for document delivery in Italy”, Interlending & Document Supply, Vol 36 No3, pp 167-177.

Murdoch, J. (2001), “Access to journals through subscriptions and document delivery : a study for year 2000”, in Ingenta Institute, Assumptions versus reality: user behaviour in sourcing scholarly information, edited proceedings of a meeting held on 25th September 2001 at the Royal Society of London, Ingenta Institute, Oxford, pp 83-95

Ortigari A. (2008), “Diritti e doveri degli utenti nella negoziazione nazionale: discesa libera o slalom speciale?,” in: Proceedings of the V Convegno Internet Document Delivery e Cooperazione Interbibliotecaria. "Tools, best practices & copyright", 21-23 Maggio 2008, Bolzano. Available at: http://puma.isti.cnr.it/dfdownload.php?ident=/cnr.bibo/2008-B2-005 (accessed on 20th October 2010)

Russon, D. (2001), “The relationship between journal subscriptions and document delivery, in Ingenta Institute”, Assumptions versus reality: user behaviour in sourcing scholarly information, edited proceedings of a meeting held on 25th September 2001 at the Royal Society of London, Ingenta Institute, Oxford, pp 7-13

Russon, D. and Campbell, R. (1996), “Access to journals: a joint publisher/librarian analysis”, Logos, Vol 7 No2, pp 178-185.

Schloegl, C. and Gorraiz, J. (2006), “Document delivery as a source for bibliometric analyses: The case of Subito”, Journal of Information Science, Vol 32 No3, pp 223-237.

Senftleben M. (2004), Copyright, Limitations and the Three-Step Test: An Analysis Of The Three-Step Test In International And EC Copyright Law, Kluwer Law International

Sykes, P. (2010), “ ‘I tell you naught for your comfort’: Budgetary prospects for academic libraries over the next few years”, Serials, Vol 23 No1,pp 6-11.

Tonta, Y. A. and Ünal, Y. (2005), “Scatter of journals and literature obsolescence reflected in document delivery requests”, Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, Vol 56 No1, pp 84-94.

Tutiya, S., Takeuchi, H., Sato, Y. and Itsumura, H. (2007), “ILL/DD in Japan across the turn of the century-Basic findings about NACSIS-ILL from 1994 to 2005”, Progress in Informatics, No, pp 29-49.

Vezzoso, S. (2005), “Document delivery e invio elettronico: profili comunitari alla luce del caso ‘Subito’”, DANTE - Diritto d'Autore e Nuove Tecnologie, Vol 1 No1, pp 7-33. Available at http://eprints.biblio.unitn.it/archive/00000916/ (accessed on 23rd July 2010)

Vezzoso, S. (2006), “Subito and Beyond: new challenges for library document delivery in Europe?”, paper presented at the IV Conference on Internet Document Delivery and library cooperation, DD services and electronic resources: the user needs, the library answers, 18-19 May 2006, Naples, Italy, available at:

http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1357322 (accessed on 23rd July 2010)

Wiley, L. and Chrzastowski, T. E. (2001), “The state of ILL in the state of IL: the Illinois Interlibrary Loan Assessment Project”, Library Collections Acquisitions & Technical Services, Vol 25 No1, pp 5-20.

Wiley, L. N. (2004), “License to Deny? Publisher restrictions on document delivery from e-licensed journals”, Interlending & Document Supply, Vol 32 No2, pp 94-102.

Wiley, L. and Chrzastowski, T. E. (2005), “The impact of electronic journals on interlibrary lending: A longitudinal study of statewide interlibrary loan article sharing in Illinois”, Library Collections Acquisitions & Technical Services, Vol 29 No4, pp 364-381.

Woodward, A. M. (1978), “Factors affecting the renewal of periodical subscriptions: a study of decision-making in libraries with special reference to economics and inter-library lending”, 0851421083, Aslib, London

Zaetta M. (2006), “Le clausole DD/ILL nelle licenze per le riviste elettroniche in Italia: politiche degli editori a confronto”, in Proceedings of the IV Convegno Internet Document Delivery e cooperazione interbibliotecaria “Servizi DD e risorse elettroniche: le esigenze degli utenti, le risposte delle biblioteche” 18-19 Maggio 2006, Napoli. Available at: http://puma.isti.cnr.it/dfdownload.php?ident=/cnr.bibo/2006-B2-015 (accessed on 20th October 2010)

Zaetta M., and Mangiaracina, S. (2008), “Document Delivery e trasmissione elettronica sicura: uno stato dell’arte”. Biblioteche oggi, Vol 26 No2, pp 25-36.

Senftleben, M. R. F. (2004) Copyright, limitations, and the three-step test : an analysis of the three-step test in international and EC copyright law, Kluwer Law International, The Hague

Proceedings of the I-V Italian conferences on Internet Document Delivery and Inter-Library Cooperation (2001 – 2008). Available at:

http://leonardo.isti.cnr.it/metaopac/servlet/Isis?Dsfor=200&Obj=%40cnr-pListtibib_r.pft%2CSortedBy%3A%40cnrSS_r_yetyti.pft&Opt=search&Field0=&Field1=&Field2=&Field8=&Field4=&Field3=B2&Field5=BIBO&Rqar=y&Conf=%2Fexport%2Fhome%2Fmetaopac%2Fmpisa%2FcnrpConf%2Fcnr_bibo-pub-list.sys.file_x&SrcWin=1&Dsfr=1

(accessed on 23rd July 2010)


Downloads

Downloads per month over past year

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item