Availability and Overlap of Quality Computer Science Journal Holdings in Selected University Libraries in Malaysia

Zainab, A.N. and Ng, S.L. Availability and Overlap of Quality Computer Science Journal Holdings in Selected University Libraries in Malaysia. Malaysian Journal of Library and Information Science, 2003, vol. 8, n. 1, pp. 45-64. [Journal article (Paginated)]

Availability and Overlap of Quality Computer Science Journal Holdings in Selected University Libraries in Malaysia.pdf

Download (82kB) | Preview

English abstract

The study reveals the availability status of quality journals in the field of computer science held in the libraries of the University of Malaya, (UM), University of Science Malaysia (USM), University of Technology Malaysia (UTM), National University of Malaysia (UKM) and University Putra Malaysia (UPM). These universities are selected since they offer degree programmes in computer science. The study also investigates the degree of overlaps and unique titles in the five libraries. The University of Malaya Library was taken as a case study to show how total overlap titles are calculated, and how possible savings and wider coverage of quality journals could be achieved if cooperative acquisition scheme is practiced. Quality journals in the study are 301 titles with calculated impact factor listed by the Journal Citation Report (JCR). The results indicate that (a) the title availability ranges from poor to very poor with 40 by UTM, 34.22 by UM, and 16 by UKM: (b) out of the 301 titles, 115 (38.2) are overlaps, 96 titles (32.23) are unique titles and 89 titles are not subscribed; (c) the percentage of unique titles and overlaps are related to the size of title availability; (d) journal titles subscribed increased by more than 50 each year (e) the cost of journal title overlaps for UM library is estimated to be about US163,170.60. This cost could be reduced and a wider coverage of unique titles could be achieved if the five libraries cooperatively acquire high impact journal titles.

Item type: Journal article (Paginated)
Keywords: Journal duplicates; Journal overlaps, Computer science; Malaysia; Impact factor journals; Collection development.
Subjects: H. Information sources, supports, channels. > HA. Periodicals, Newspapers.
L. Information technology and library technology
Depositing user: Miss Nur Jannatul Adnin Ahmad Shafawi
Date deposited: 21 Jan 2013 10:45
Last modified: 02 Oct 2014 12:24
URI: http://hdl.handle.net/10760/18263


1998 National survey of research and development. 1999. Kuala Lumpur: Ministry of Science, Technology and the Environment, Malaysia.

Altman, E. 1972. Implications of the title diversity and collection overlap for interlibrary loan among secondary schools. Library Quarterly, Vol.42, no.2:177-194.

Altman, Klaus G. and Gorman, G.E. 1998. The usefulness of impact factors in serial selection: a rank and mean analysis using ecology journals. Library Acquisition: Practice and Theory, vol.22, no.2:147-159.

Barstow, Sandra. 1993. Quickly selecting serials for cancellation. Technical Services Quarterly, Vol.104: 29-42.

Bosch, Stephen and Simons, Nancy. 1996. Reducing rates of inflation: serials cancellations at the University of Arizona. Technical Services Quarterly, Vol.14, no.1: 49-65.

Buffardi, Louis C. and Nichols, Julia. 1985. Citation impact, acceptance rate and APA Journals, American Psychologist, Vol.36: 1456.

Chrzastowski, Tina E. and Schmidt, Karen A.1996. Collections at risk: revisiting serials cancellations in academic libraries. College and Research Libraries, Vol.57, no.4: 351-364.

Cooper, W.S.; Thompson, D.D. and Weeks, K.R. 1975. The duplication of monograph holdings in the University of California Library System. Library Quarterly, Vol.45, no.3: 235-273.

Fedunok, Suzanne. 1998. Proposals for inter-institutional serials cooperation at the SUNY Centres. College and Research Libraries, Vol 59, no. 2: 67-77.

Fjallbrant, Nancy. 1984. Rationalization of periodical holdings: a case study at Chalmers University Library. Journal of Academic Librarianship, vol.10:77-86.

German, R.N.; Kidd, T. and Pratt, G. 1997. Serials overlap in the Higher education institution libraries in Glasgow. The New Review of Academic Librarianship, Vol.3: 115-138.

Hooper, A,S.C. 1990. Overlapping journal subscriptions as a factor in University library cooperation. South African Journal of Library and Information Science, Vol.58, no.1: 25-32.

Knightly, J.J. 1975. Library collections and academic curricula: quantitative relationships. College and Research Libraries, Vol. 36: 295-301.

Kreider, Janice. 1999. The correlation of local citation data with citation data from Journal Citation Report. Library Resources & Technical Services, Vol.43, no.2: 67-77.

Malaysia. 1996. Fifth Malaysia Plan 19991-1995. Kuala Lumpur: National Printing Office.

Malaysia. 1991. Sixth Malaysia Plan 19991-1995. Kuala Lumpur: National Printing Office.

Meadows, Jack. 2000. Why do we need serials? In: T. Kidd and L. Rees-Jones (ed), The serials management handbook. London : Library Association.

Moore, B; Miller, T. and Tolliver, D.L. 1980. Title overlap: a study of duplication at the University of Wisconsin system libraries. College and Research Libraries, Vol. 43, no.1: 14-21.

Nisonger, Thomas E. 1994. A methodological issue concerning the use of social sciences Citation Index Journal Citation Reports impact factor data for journal ranking. Library Acquisition: Practice & Theory, vol.16, no.4: 447-458.

Page, G. ; Campbell, R. and Meadows, J. 1997. Journal Publishing. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Potters, W.G. 1982. Studies of collection overlap: a literature review, Library Research, Vol.4, no.1: 3-21.

Potters, W.G. 1986. Collection overlap in the LCS network in Illinois. Library Quarterly, Vol. 56, no.2: 119-141.

Rutledge, John and Swindler, Luke. 1987. The selection decision: defining criteria and establishing priorities. College and Research Libraries, Vol.48: 123-131.

Sen, B.K. and Mashkuri Yaacob. 1997. The ever widening gap. University News,35(8): 11-14, 18.

Strubbe, Lisa Ann. 1989. Characteristics of serials duplication within an academic research library. Library & Information Science Research, Vol.11, no.2: 91-108

Ulrich’s International Periodicals Directory.

Walter, Pat L. 1990. Doing the unthinkable: canceling journals at a research library. Serials Librarian. Vol.8: 141-153.


Downloads per month over past year

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item