Excellence or quality? Impact of the current competition regime on science and scientific publishing in Latin America and its implications for development

Vessuri, Hebe and Guédon, Jean-Claude and Cetto, Ana María Excellence or quality? Impact of the current competition regime on science and scientific publishing in Latin America and its implications for development. Current Sociology, 2013. [Journal article (Print/Paginated)]


Download (361Kb) | Preview

English abstract

The current competition regime that characterizes international science is often presented as a quest for excellence. It diversely affects research in Latin America and research in the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries. This article asks how this competition regime may orient the direction of research in Latin America, and to whose advantage. It is argued that, by relating excellence to quality differently, a research policy that seeks to improve the level of science in Latin America while preserving the possibility of solving problems relevant to the region can be designed. Competition, it is also argued, certainly has its place in science, but not as a general management tool, especially if the goal is to improve overall quality of science in Latin America. Scientific competition is largely managed through journals and their reputation. Therefore, designing a science policy for Latin America (and for any ‘peripheral’ region of the world) requires paying special attention to the mechanisms underpinning the production, circulation and consumption of scientific journals. So-called ‘international’ or ‘core’ journals are of particular interest as local, national, or even regional journals must struggle to find their place in this peculiar publishing eco-system.

Item type: Journal article (Print/Paginated)
Keywords: Excellence, Latin America, open access journals, quality and research evaluation, research policy, scientific competition, scientific recognition
Subjects: B. Information use and sociology of information. > BA. Use and impact of information.
B. Information use and sociology of information. > BE. Information economics.
B. Information use and sociology of information. > BG. Information dissemination and diffusion.
H. Information sources, supports, channels. > HR. Portals.
H. Information sources, supports, channels. > HS. Repositories.
Depositing user: Jean-Claude Guédon
Date deposited: 01 Sep 2014 03:50
Last modified: 02 Oct 2014 12:32
URI: http://hdl.handle.net/10760/23682


"SEEK" links will first look for possible matches inside E-LIS and query Google Scholar if no results are found.

Aguado-López E (2011) REDALYC.ORG: Nueve años haciendo visible la ciencia iberoameri-cana. In: Cetto AM and Alonso GJO (eds) Calidad e Impacto de la Revista Iberoamericana, 1st edn. México: Facultad de Ciencias, UNAM. Available at: www.latindex.unam.mx/libro-ciri/ (accessed 15 June 2013).

Alperín JP, Fischman GE and Willinsky J (2011) Scholarly communication strategies in Latin America’s research-intensive universities. Educación Superior y Sociedad 16(2). Special Issue on the Impact of Open Access in Higher Education in Latin America. UNESCO-IESALC.

Brage S (2011) Directory of Open Access Journals and its impact on the open access movement with a special perspective on Latin America. In: Cetto AM and Alonso GJO (eds) Calidad e Impacto de la Revista Iberoamericana, 1st edn. México: Facultad de Ciencias, UNAM. Available at: www.latindex.unam.mx/librociri/ (accessed 15 June 2013).

Brembs B and Munafò M (2013) Deep impact: Unintended consequences of journal rank. Available at: arxiv.org/abs/1301.3748

De SN (1959) Enterotoxicity of bacteria-free culture filtrate of Vibrio cholerae. Nature 183: 1533–1534. Available at: www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/13666809

Declaración de Salvador (2005) Declaración de Salvador sobre ‘Acceso Abierto’: la perspectiva del mundo en desarrollo. ICML 9/CRICS 7, Salvador, Bahia, Brazil, 20–23 September. Available at: www.icml9.org (accessed 20 June 2013).

Encuentro las Universidades Latinoamericanas ante los Rankings Internacionales: Impactos, Alcances y Límites (2012) Declaración Final. Mexico City, 18 May. Available at: www.encuentro-rankings.unam.mx/Documentos/Final-declaration-spanish.pdf (accessed 15 June 2013).

Falagas ME and Alexiou VG (2008) The top-ten in journal impact factor manipulation. Archivum Immunologiae et Therapiae Experimentalis 56(4): 223–226.

Fang FC, Steen RG and Casadevall A (2012) Misconduct accounts for the majority of retracted scientific publications. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 109(42):17028–17033.

Garfield E (1986) Mapping cholera research and the impact of Sambhu Nath De of Calcutta. Current Contents 14: 3–11.

Guédon J-C (2001) In Oldenburg’s Long Shadow: Librarians, Research Scientists, Publishers, and the Control of Scientific Publishing. Washington, DC: ARL. Available at: www.arl.org/storage/documents/publications/in-oldenburgs-long-shadow.pdf (accessed 15 June 2013).

Guédon J-C (2011) Between quality and excellence; from nation to region: Strategies for Latin American scholarly and scientific journals. In: Cetto AM and Alonso GJO (eds) Calidad e Impacto de la Revista Iberoamericana. México: Facultad de Ciencias, UNAM. Available at: www.latindex.unam.mx/librociri/ (accessed 15 June 2013).

Horton R (2009) Quoted in Z Corbyn: A threat to scientific communication. The Times Higher Education, 14 August. Available at: www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/407705.article (accessed 9 June 2013).

Macpherson CB (1962) The Political Theory of Possessive Individualism: Hobbes to Locke. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Mabe M (2003) The growth and number of journals. Serials 16(2). Available at: uksg.metapress.com/content/f195g8ak0eu21muh/fulltext.pdf

Ortiz R (2009) La Supremacía del Inglés en las Ciencias Sociales. Buenos Aires: Siglo XXI Editores.

Packer A and Meneghini R (2007) Learning to communicate science in developing countries. Interciencia 32(9): 643–647.

Plaz Power I and Vessuri H (2009) La digitalización de la Biblioteca Marcel Roche: Condición para el aprendizaje informacional científico tecnológico. In: Aguirre J and Carnota R (eds) Historia de la Informática en América Latina y el Caribe: Investigaciones y Testimonies. Córdoba: Universidad Nacional de Rio Cuarto.

Readings B (1996) The University in Ruins. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

RICyt (2002) El Estado de la Ciencia. Principales Indicadores de Ciencia y Tecnología Iberoamericanos/Interamericanos 2001. Buenos Aires: Red Iberoamericana de Indicadores de Ciencia y Tecnología (RICyT).

Russell JM (1995) The increasing role of international cooperation in science and technology research in Mexico. Scientometrics 1(1): 45–61.

Russell JM et al. (2008) Mexican collaboration networks in the international and regional arenas. In: WIS 2008, Fourth International Conference on Webometrics, Informetrics and Scientometrics and Ninth COLLNBET Meeting, Berlin, 28 July–1 August. Available at: fiz1.fh-potsdam.de/volltext/wis08/09073.pdf (accessed 10 October 2013).

San Francisco Declaration (2012) San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment: Putting science into the assessment of research. Available at: am.ascb.org/dora/ (accessed 20 June 2013).

Vessuri H (1997) Sobre los indicadores de desempeño en las ciencias sociales. In: Jaramillo H and Albornoz M (eds) El Universo de la Medición: La Perspectiva de la Ciencia y la Tecnología. Santafe de Bogotá: COLCIENCIAS/CYTED /TM Editores.

Vessuri H (2004) History of science and policy implications in a developing country setting. In: Gradin K, Wormbs N and Widmalm S (eds) The Science–Industry Nexus: History, Policy, Implications, Nobel Symposia 123. Cambridge: Science History Publications.

Wagner C (2008) The New Invisible College: Science for Development. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item