Challenging the "love of possessions": Repatriation of sacred objects in the United States and Canada

Dekker, Jennifer Challenging the "love of possessions": Repatriation of sacred objects in the United States and Canada. Collections: A Journal for Museum and Archives Professionals, 2018, vol. 14, n. 1, pp. 37-62. [Journal article (Paginated)]

[img]
Preview
Text
Dekker_Challenging_Love_Possessions-submitted.pdf

Download (690kB) | Preview

English abstract

In 1990, the US passed the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act, requiring the repatriation of ancestral remains, funerary and sacred objects from museums to source communities. Since then, hundreds of thousands of repatriations have occurred, allowing for respectful treatment of ancestors and reconnections to spiritual, communal practice and ceremony. In Canada, repatriation has been recommended by the Assembly of First Nations, the Canadian Museums Association and the UNDRIP but there is no federal law. Does Canada have a functioning alternative? This review provides a comparative analysis of how repatriation differs in the two countries, arguing that case-by-case negotiations in Canada currently allow for more flexibility and customization to the needs of different Indigenous communities, but that the transparency and financing associated with NAGPRA would be a significant benefit to Indigenous peoples in Canada.

Item type: Journal article (Paginated)
Keywords: Indigenous cultural property, NAGPRA, Repatriation, Sacred Objects, Museums, Canada
Subjects: D. Libraries as physical collections. > DM. Museums.
J. Technical services in libraries, archives, museum. > JA. Acquisitions.
Depositing user: Ms. Jennifer Dekker
Date deposited: 28 Aug 2018 22:13
Last modified: 28 Aug 2018 22:13
URI: http://hdl.handle.net/10760/33374

References

135 Cong. Rec. S12363-S12468 (daily ed. October 3, 1989) (statement of Mr. Moynihan).

Akhtar, Zia. “Storytelling as Testimony and the Rule against Hearsay.” In Trial Evidence.Chicago: American Bar Association, 2017.

Alberta. “First Nations Sacred Ceremonial Objects Repatriation Act, RSA 2000.” c. F-14, 2016.

“American Collections.” Horniman Museum and Gardens,

https://www.horniman.ac.uk/collections/american-collections.

Assembly of First Nations and Canadian Museum Association. “Turning the Page: Forging New Partnerships between Museums and First Peoples.” Ottawa: Canada Council for the Arts, 1994.

Baird, Jill R., Anjuli Solanki, and Mique’l Askren, eds. Returning the Past: Repatriation of First Nations Cultural Property: Four Case Studies of First Nations Repatriation. Vancouver: Museum of Anthropology at the University of British Columbia, 2008.

Barrera, Jorge. “Liberal MP’s Bill Aims to Create National Strategy for Repatriating Indigenous Cultural Items.” CBC News, February 3 2018.

Bell, Catherine, and Heather McCuaig. “Protection and Repatriation of Ktunaxa/Kinbasket Cultural Resources: Perspectives of Community Members.” In First Nations Cultural Heritage and Law: Case Studies, Voices and Perspectives, edited by Catherine Bell and Val Napoleon, 312-64. Vancouver: UBC Press, 2008.

Bell, Catherine, and R.K. Paterson. Aboriginal Rights to Cultural Property in Canada. International Journal of Cultural Property 8, no. 1 (1999): 167-211.

Bell, Catherine, Graham Statt, and Michael Solowan. "First Nations Cultural Heritage: A Selected Survey of Issues and Initiatives." In First Nations Cultural Heritage and Law: Case Studies, Voices and Perspectives, edited by Catherine Bell and Val Napoleon, 367-414. Vancouver: UBC Press, 2008.

Bell, Catherine, Heather Raven and Heather McCuaig in consultation with Andrea Sanborn, the U’Mista Cultural Society, and the ‘Namgis Nation. “Recovering from Colonization: Perspectives of Community Members on Protection and Repatriation of KwaKwaka’wakw Cultural Heritage.” In First Nations Cultural Heritage and Law: Case Studies, Voices and Perspectives, edited by Catherine Bell and Val Napoleon, 33-91. Vancouver: UBC Press, 2008.

Bill C-391. An Act Respecting a National Strategy for the Repatriation of Aboriginal Cultural Property of 2018.” 1st sess., 42 nd Parliament, 2018, HCC 64-65-66.

Blair, S., T. Jarratt, and P. Ward. “Weaving Together Two Ways of Knowing: Archaeological Organic Artifact Analysis and Indigenous Textile Arts.” North American Archaeologist 35, no. 4 (2104): 295-302.

Campbell, Emmy-Lou. “The Transformative Power of T’xwelátse: A Collaborative Case Study in Search of New Approaches to Indigenous Cultural Repatriation Processes.” University of Victoria, 2010.

Canada. Indigenous and Northern Affairs. “United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.” Ottawa, 2017.

Canada. Parliament. Senate. Standing Senate Committee on Aboriginal Peoples. Border Crossing Issues and the Jay Treaty. 1 st sess., 42 nd Parliament, 2016.

Chari, Sangita, and Jaime M.N. Lavallee, eds. Accomplishing NAGPRA: Perspectives on the Intent, Impact and Future of the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act. Corvallis: Oregon State University, 2013.

Child, Brenda J. “Introduction: Creation of the Tribal Museum.” In Contesting Knowledge: Museums and Indigenous Perspectives, edited by Susan Sleeper-Smith, 251-56. Lincoln: University of Nebraska, 2009.

Claw, Katrina G., Dorothy Lippert, Jessica Bardill, Anna Cordova, Keolu Fox, Joseph Yracheta, Alyssa C. Bader, et al. “Chaco Canyon Dig Unearths Ethical Concerns.” Human Biology Open Access Pre-Prints 122 (2017).

Conaty, Gerald T. “The Effects of Repatriation on the Relationship between the Glenbow Museum and the Blackfoot People.” Museum Management and Curatorship 23, no. 3 (2008): 245-59.

Curtis, Neil G.W. “Repatriation from Scottish Museums: Learning from NAGPRA.” Museum Anthropology 33, no. 2 (2010): 234-48.

Dibbelt, Dan. “Nations Gather to Protest Glenbow’s Spirit Sings Display.” Windspeaker 5, no.23 (1988): 2.

Ewing, Robyn G. “Finding Middle Ground: Case Studies in Negotiated Repatriation.” MA diss., Simon Fraser, 2011.

Fenton, William N. “Return of Eleven Wampum Belts to the Six Nations Iroquois Confederacy on Grand River, Canada.” Ethnohistory 36, no. 4 (1989): 392-410.

France. Sénat. “Loi n. 2010-501 du 18 mai 2010 visant à autoriser la restitution par la France des têtes Maories à la Nouvelle-Zélande et relative à la gestion des collections.” Harding, Sarah K. “Justifying Repatriation of Native American Cultural Property.” Indiana Law Journal 72, no. 723 (1997): 724-74. International Council of Museums. ICOM Code of Ethics for Museums. Paris: ICOM, 2017.

Jacknis, Ira. “A New Thing? The National Museum of the American Indian in Historical and Institutional Perspective.” In The National Museum of the American Indian: Critical Conversations, edited by Amy Lonetree and Amanda J. Cobb, 3-42. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2008.

Jenkins, Tiffany. Contesting Human Remains in Museum Collections: The Crisis of Cultural Authority. New York: Routledge, 2011.

Jessiman, Stacey R. “The Edgy State of Decolonization at the Canadian Museum of History.” University of British Columbia Law Review 47, no. 3 (2014): 889-925.

Keeler, Honor. A Guide to International Repatriation: Starting an Initiative in Your Community. Rockville, MD: American Association for Indian Affairs, 2015.

“Kennewick Man, the Ancient One.” Seattle: Burke Museum, 2017.

Krmpotich, Cara, and Laura Peers. This Is Our Life: Haida Material Heritage and Changing Museum Practice. Vancouver: UBC Press, 2014.

Kuprecht, Karolina. Indigenous Peoples' Cultural Property Claims: Repatriation and Beyond. Switzerland: Springer International Publishing, 2014.

Langlois, Marie-Claude. “Canada’s National Museums.” Ottawa, 2013.

Lenzerini, Frederico. “Cultural Identity, Human Rights, and Repatriation of Cultural Heritage of Indigenous Peoples.” Brown Journal of World Affairs 23, no. 1 (2016): 127-41.

Logan, Marty. “Museum, Kitigan Zibi in Tug of War over Remains.” Windspeaker 20, no. 10 (2003): 24-28.

Lonetree, Amy. Decolonizing Museums: Representing Native America in National and Tribal Museums. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2012.

McKeown, C. Timothy. In the Smaller Scope of Conscience: The Struggle for National Repatriation Legislation, 1986-1990. Tucson: University of Arizona Press, 2012.

McKeown, C. Timothy, Emily Palus, Jennifer Riordan, and Richard Waldbauer. “Federal Agency Perspective.” In Accomplishing NAGPRA: Perspectives on the Intent, Impact and Future of the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act, edited by Sangita Chari and Jaime M.N. Lavallee, 135-60. Corvallis: University of Oregon Press, 2013.

Meister, Barbara, ed. Mending the Circle: A Native American Repatriation Guide. New York: The American Indian Ritual Object Repatriation Foundation, 1997.

“MP Bill Casey Introduces Aboriginal Cultural Property Repatriation Act.”

https://bcasey.liberal.ca/news-nouvelles/working-together-to-repatriate-cultural-

property/.

Narine, Shari. “Repatriation of Sacred Objects Should Be Overseen by Indigenous Committee.” Windspeaker 34, no. 7 (2016): 21-22.

National Congress of American Indians. “Support for International Repatriation: Resolution #Sac-12-008.” http://www.ncai.org/resources/resolutions/support-for-international-repatriation.

O’Neill, Mark. “Repatriation and Its Discontents: The Glasgow Experience.” In Who Owns Objects? The Ethics and Politics of Collecting Cultural Artefacts, edited by Eleanor Robson, Luke Treadwell and Chris Gosden, 105-28. Oxford: Oxbow, 2004.

Ontario Human Rights Commission. “Policy on Preventing Discrimination Based on Creed: Indigenous Spiritual Practices.” 2015.

“Our History.” New York: American Indian Ritual Object Repatriation Foundation, 2018.

Peck, Danielle, and Alex Seaborn, producers. “Bones of Contention: Native American Archaeology” London: BBC, 1995.

Platzman, Steven. “Objects of Controversy: The Native American Right to Repatriation.” American University Law Review 41, no. 2 (1992): 517-58.

Rasmussen, Morten, Martin Sikora, Anders Albrechsten, Thorfinn Sand Korneliussen, and J. Victor Moreno-Mayar. “The Ancestry and Affiliation of Kennewick Man.” Nature 523 (2015): 455-58.

Saskatchewan. “Royal Saskatchewan Museum Act.” c.R-23.01 Regina: Legislative Assembly of Saskatchewan, 2007.

Siegfried, Evelyn. “Repatriation of Sacred and Ceremonial Objects: The Royal Saskatchewan Museum Story.” Regina: Royal Saskatchewan Museum, 2014.

Smilie, Christine Marie. “The People Left out of Treaty 8.” MA diss., University of Saskatchewan, 2005.

Smith, Cathay Y.N. “Oral Tradition and Kennewick Man.” Yale Law Journal Forum 126 (2016): 216-31.

UNESCO. “Intergovernmental Committee (ICPRCP).” Paris: UNESCO, 2017.

———. “International Code of Ethics for Dealers in Cultural Property.” Paris: UNESCO, 1999.

———. “Return or Restitution Cases.” Paris, UNESCO, 2017.

United Nations, Division for Social Policy and Development, Indigenous Peoples. “United Nations Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.” New York: United Nations, 2008.

U.S. Department of the Interior. National Park Service. “Determining Cultural Affiliation within NAGPRA.” Washington, DC: National Park Service, 2013.

———. “NAGPRA Glossary.” Washington, DC: National Park Service.

———. “NAGPRA Grants.” Washington, DC: National Park Service, 2017.

———. “National NAGPRA.” Washington, DC: National Park Service.

———. “National NAGPRA Online Databases.” Washington, DC: National Park Service, 2018.

Weasel Head, Frank. “Repatriation Experiences of the Kainai.” In We Are Coming Home: Repatriation and the Restoration of Blackfoot Cultural Confidence, edited by Gerald T. Conaty, 151-81. Athabasca: AU Press, 2015.

Weber, Bob. “Precious Ceremonial Objects Slowly Being Returned to First Nations from Museums.” Global News, December 15, 2017.

Weiss, Elizabeth. Reburying the Past: The Effects of Repatriation and Reburial on Scientific Inquiry. New York: Nova Science, 2008.

Whalen, Julia. “Pipe Chief Calls for Royal Ontario Museum to Return Indigenous Artifacts.” CBC News (June 20, 2017).

Whittam, Julian. ‘“In a Good Way”’: Repatriation, Community and Development in Kitigan Zibi." Anthropologica 57, no. 2 (2015): 501-09.

Whyte, Murray. “Long Road to Recovery for Indigenous Sacred Objects.” Toronto Star, November 17 2017.

Wunderlich, Caitlin S. “Museum Sector Policy Deficit: Repatriation from United States Museums.” The Museum Scholar, 1, no. 1 (2017).


Downloads

Downloads per month over past year

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item