Moral Education (2010-2019): A Bibliometric Study (Part 1)

[1] J Liang. A revisit of ‘moral and character education’ subject in

junior-high school in China. China Journal of Social Work.

2016;9(2):103-11.

[2] I Rissanen, E Kuusisto, E Hanhimäki, K Tirri. The

implications of teachers’ implicit theories for moral education:

A case study from Finland. Journal of Moral Education.

2018;47(1):63-77.

[3] G Kärrby. Moral Education in Sweden. Journal of Moral

Education. 1978;8(1):14-22.

[4] L Jie, G Desheng. New directions in the moral education

curriculum in Chinese primary schools. Journal of Moral

Education. 2004;33(4):495-510.

[5] Y Khan. Japanese moral education past and present: Fairleigh

Dickinson Univ Press; 1997.

[6] H Wray, editor The fall of moral education and the rise and

decline of civics education and social studies in occupied and

independent Japan. Japan Forum; 2000: Taylor & Francis.

[7] MH Roesgaard. ‘The Ideal Citizen’, Globalization, and the

Japanese Response: Risk, Gate-keeping, and Moral Education

in Japan.’. Reimagining Japanese Education: borders,

transfers, circulations, and the comparative. 2011.

[8] R Sakamoto. Can morals be taught? An exploratory study on

recent changes in the Japanese moral education curriculum.

International Journal of Educational Reform.

2008;17(2):153-68.

[9] R Tsuneyoshi. Japanese model of schooling: Comparisons

with the US: Routledge; 2013.

[10] Z Fadeeva, Y Mochizuki, DM Podger, E Mustakova ‐

Possardt, A Reid. A whole‐person approach to educating for

sustainability. International Journal of Sustainability in

Higher Education. 2010.

[11] LE Wolf‐Wendel, M Ruel. Developing the whole student:

The collegiate ideal. New directions for higher education.

1999;1999(105):35-46.

[12] S Anzai. Re-examining patriotism in Japanese education:

analysis of Japanese elementary school moral readers.

Educational Review. 2015;67(4):436-58.

[13] KT Pak. Contesting Children’s Citizenship Education: What

Should Japanese Children Know? Power in contemporary

Japan: Springer; 2016. p. 21-38.

[14] C Yasaroglu. Teachers’ Opinions on the Effectiveness of Life

Science Curriculum in Values Education. The Anthropologist.

2015;20(3):510-4.

[15] SD Hoffman. School texts, the written word, and political

indoctrination: A review of moral education curricula in

modern Japan (1886–1997). History of Education.

1999;28(1):87-96.

[16] S Wright. ‘There is something universal in our movement

which appeals not only to one country, but to all’:

international communication and moral education 1892–1914.

History of Education. 2008;37(6):807-24.

[17] S Wright. Morality and Citizenship in English Schools.

Secular Approaches 1897-1944. 2017.

[18] W-C Ho. Moral education in China’s music education:

Development and challenges. International Journal of Music

Education. 2010;28(1):71-87.

[19] A Parker. Education May Help Decrease Nurses’ Moral

Distress. American Journal of Critical Care.

2013;22(4):286-7.

[20] LC Wang, L Calvano. Is business ethics education effective?

An analysis of gender, personal ethical perspectives, and

moral judgment. Journal of Business Ethics.

2015;126(4):591-602.

[21] K Shaaban. A proposed framework for incorporating moral

education into the ESL/EFL classroom. Language, Culture

and Curriculum. 2005;18(2):201-17.

[22] S Thongrin. Integrating moral education into language

education in Asia: Guidelines for materials writers. Situating

Moral and Cultural Values in ELT Materials: Springer; 2018.

p. 153-73.

[23] GK Sidhu, S Kaur, CY Fook. Analysing the Integration of

Moral and Cultural Values through ELT Reading Materials in

Malaysian ESL Classrooms. Situating moral and cultural

values in ELT materials: Springer; 2018. p. 69-85.

[24] L Van Canh. A Critical Analysis of Moral Values in

Vietnam-Produced EFL Textbooks for Upper Secondary

Schools. Situating Moral and Cultural Values in ELT

Materials: The Southeast Asian Context. 2018:111-29.

[25] M Bolognani. Community perceptions of moral education as a

response to crime by young Pakistani males in Bradford.

Journal of Moral Education. 2007; 36(3):357-69.

[26] G Feuerverger. Oasis of Peace: a community of moral

education in Israel. Journal of Moral Education. 1995;

24(2):113-41.

[27] CJ An. Participation, not paternalism: Moral education,

normative competence and the child’s entry into the moral

community. Educational Philosophy and Theory. 2020;

52(2):192-205.

[28] L Nucci. Synthesis of research on moral development.

Educational Leadership. 1987; 44(5):86-92.

[29] PT Begley, J Stefkovich. Integrating Values and Ethics into

Post Secondary Teaching for Leadership Development:

Principles, Concepts, and Strategies. Journal of Educational

Administration. 2007; 45(4):398-412.

[30] T Gilead. Progress or stability? An historical approach to a central question for moral education. Journal of Moral

Education. 2009; 38(1):93-107.

[31] L D’Olimpio. Moral education within the social contract:

Whose contract is it anyway? Journal of Moral Education.

2019; 48(4):515-28.

[32] K Roth. Education and a progressive orientation towards a

cosmopolitan society. Ethics and Education. 2012;7(1):59-73.

[33] MM Blatt, L Kohlberg. The Effects of Classroom Moral

Discussion upon Children's Level of Moral Judgment. Journal

of Moral Education. 1975; 4(2):129-61.

[34] I Foster, J Wyman, V Talwar. Moral disengagement: a new

lens with which to examine children’s justifications for lying.

Journal of Moral Education. 2019:1-17.

[35] L Gasser, T Malti, E Gutzwiller-Helfenfinger. Aggressive and

Nonaggressive Children's Moral Judgments and Moral

Emotion Attributions in Situations Involving Retaliation and

Unprovoked Aggression. The Journal of Genetic Psychology.

2012; 173(4):417-39.

[36] SM Hall. Moral geographies of family: articulating, forming

and transmitting moralities in everyday life. Social & Cultural

Geography. 2016; 17(8):1017-39.

[37] SE Oladipo. Moral Education of the Child: Whose

Responsibility? Journal of Social Sciences. 2009;

20(2):149-56.

[38] H Alexander. Taking Back the Public Square: Peaceful

Coexistence through Pedagogies of the Sacred, of Difference,

and of Hope. Religious Education. 2019; 114(4):417-23.

[39] M Zembylas. Toleration and coexistence in conflicting

societies: some tensions and implications for education.

Pedagogy, Culture & Society. 2011; 19(3):385-402.

[40] WA Nord, CC Haynes. The relationship of religion to moral

education in the public schools. George Washington

University: The Communitarian Network. 2000.

[41] WD Feng. Infusing moral education into English language

teaching: an ontogenetic analysis of social values in EFL

textbooks in Hong Kong. Discourse: Studies in the Cultural

Politics of Education. 2019;40(4):458-73.

[42] M Islami. Character Values and Their Internalization in

Teaching and Learning English at Madrasah. Dinamika Ilmu.

2016;16(2):279-89.

[43] M-Y Wong. Beyond asking ‘should’and ‘why’questions:

Contextualised questioning techniques for moral discussions

in moral education classes. Journal of Moral Education.

2020:1-16.

[44] EP Sugrue. Moral Injury among Professionals in K–12

Education. American Educational Research Journal.

2020;57(1):43-68.

[45] AJ Corsa. Empathy and moral education, Theatre of the

Oppressed, and The Laramie Project. Journal of Moral

Education. 2020:1-14.

[46] C Valor, P Antonetti, A Merino. The relationship between

moral competences and sustainable consumption among

higher education students. Journal of Cleaner Production.

2020; 248:119161.

[47] S Knight, BW Hayhoe, L Frith, M Ashworth, I Sajid, A

Papanikitas. Ethics education and moral decision-making in

clinical commissioning: an interview study. British Journal of

General Practice. 2020; 70(690):45-54.

[48] A Friedlander. The implications of information technology for

scientific journal publishing: a literature review: National

Science Foundation; 2003.

[49] B Cronin. Scholarly communication and epistemic cultures.

New review of academic librarianship. 2003;9(1):1-24.

[50] C Tenopir, DW King, J Spencer, L Wu. Variations in article

seeking and reading patterns of academics: What makes a

difference? Library & Information Science Research. 2009;

31(3):139-48.

[51] DW King, C Tenopir, S Choemprayong, L Wu. Scholarly

journal information‐seeking and reading patterns of faculty

at five US universities. Learned Publishing. 2009;

22(2):126-44.

[52] C Tenopir, R Mays, L Wu. Journal article growth and reading

patterns. New Review of Information Networking.

2011;16(1):4-22.

[53] M Bordons. Evaluación de la actividad científica a través de

indicadores bibliométricos [Evaluation of scientific activity

through bibliometric indicators]. Revista española de

cardiología. 1999;52(10):790-800.

[54] F De-Moya-Anegón, Z Chinchilla-Rodríguez, E

Corera-Álvarez, FJ Muñoz-Fernández, J Navarrete-Cortés.

Indicadores bibliométricos de la actividad científica

española:(ISI, Web of science, 1998-2002) [Bibliometric

indicators of Spanish scientific activity: (ISI, Web of science,

1998-2002)]: FECYT-Ministerio de Educación y Ciencia,

Spain; 2004.

[55] F López-Muñoz, C Alamo, FJ Quintero-Gutiérrez, P

García-García. A bibliometric study of international scientific

productivity in attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder

covering the period 1980–2005. European child & adolescent

psychiatry. 2008;17(6):381-91.

[56] F López-Muñoz, P García-García, J Sáiz-Ruiz, J Mezzich, G

Rubio, E Vieta, et al. A bibliometric study of the use of the

classification and diagnostic systems in psychiatry over the

last 25 years. Psychopathology. 2008;41(4):214-25.

[57] J Ramos, F Gutierrez, M Masia, A Martin-Hidalgo.

Publication of European Union research on infectious

diseases (1991–2001): a bibliometric evaluation. European

Journal of Clinical Microbiology and Infectious Diseases.

2004; 23(3):180-4.

[58] B Velasco, JME Bouza, JM Pinilla, JA San Román. La

utilización de los indicadores bibliométricos para evaluar la

actividad investigadora. Aula abierta. 2012; 40(2):75-84.

[59] JN Cudina, JC Ossa. The top 100 high-impact papers in

Colombian psychology: a bibliometric study from WoS and

Scopus. Informação & Sociedade. 2016; 26(2).

[60] R Quevedo-Blasco, T Ariza. Twenty-five year history of the

journal Psicothema. Psicothema. 2013;25(1):93-9.

[61] P Cunningham. The evaluation of european programmes and

the future of scientometrics. Scientometrics. 1997;

38(1):71-85.

[62] R Panat. On the data and analysis of the research output of

India and China: India has significantly fallen behind China.

Scientometrics. 2014; 100(2):471-81.

[63] JMF Batanero, MMR Rebollo, MM Rueda. Impact of ICT on

students with high abilities. Bibliographic review (2008–

2018). Computers & Education. 2019; 137:48-58.

[64] AR Mathankar. Bibliometrics: An overview. International

Journal of Library & Information Science (IJLIS). 2018;

7(3):9-15.

[65] İ Şeref, B Karagöz. A bibliometric profile of literature of

Turkish language education-teaching: A case study of 9th

International Language Education-Teaching Conference.

European Journal of Alternative Education Studies. 2019.

[66] İ Şeref, B Karagöz. An Evaluation of Turkish Education

Academic Field: Bibliometric Analysis Based on Web of

Science Database [Türkçe Eğitimi Akademik Alanına İlişkin

Bir Değerlendirme: Web of Science Veri Tabanına Dayalı

Bibliyometrik İnceleme]. Journal of Language Education and

Research. 2019; 5(2):213-31.

[67] JM Fernández Batanero, M Montenegro Rueda, J Fernández

Cerero, I García Martínez. Impact of the Information and

Communication Technologies on the Education of Students

with Down Syndrome: a Bibliometric Study (2008-2018).

European Journal of Educational Research, 9 (1), 79-89.

2019.

[68] EJ Beh. Simple correspondence analysis: a bibliographic

review. International Statistical Review. 2004; 72(2):257-84.

[69] A Rouilly, L Rigal. Agro-materials: a bibliographic review.

Journal of Macromolecular Science, Part C: Polymer Reviews.

2002; 42(4):441-79.

[70] M Shareefa, V Moosa. The Most-cited Educational Research

Publications on Differentiated Instruction: A Bibliometric

Analysis. European Journal of Educational Research. 2020;

9(1):331-49.

[71] HF Moed. Citation analysis in research evaluation: Springer

Science & Business Media; 2006.

[72] HF Moed. New developments in the use of citation analysis in

research evaluation. Archivum immunologiae et therapiae

experimentalis. 2009;57(1):13.

[73] LI Meho, K Yang. Impact of data sources on citation counts

and rankings of LIS faculty: Web of Science versus Scopus

and Google Scholar. Journal of the american society for

information science and technology. 2007;58(13):2105-25.

[74] AF Van Raan. Comparison of the Hirsch-index with standard

bibliometric indicators and with peer judgment for 147

chemistry research groups. scientometrics.

2006;67(3):491-502.

[75] BS Ballew. Elsevier's Scopus® Database. Journal of

Electronic Resources in Medical Libraries. 2009;6(3):245-52.

[76] L Salisbury. Web of Science and Scopus: A comparative

review of content and searching capabilities. The Charleston

Advisor. 2009;11(1):5-18.

[77] C López-Illescas, F de Moya-Anegón, HF Moed. Coverage

and citation impact of oncological journals in the Web of

Science and Scopus. Journal of informetrics.

2008;2(4):304-16.

[78] FJ Martínez-López, JM Merigó, JC Gázquez-Abad, JL

Ruiz-Real. Industrial marketing management: Bibliometric

overview since its foundation. Industrial Marketing

Management. 2019.

[79] MN Hudha, I Hamidah, A Permanasari, AG Abdullah, I

Rachman, T Matsumoto. Low Carbon Education: A Review

and Bibliometric Analysis. European Journal of Educational

Research. 2020;9(1):319-29.

[80] N Shukla, JM Merigó, T Lammers, L Miranda. Half a century

of Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine: A

bibliometric analysis from 1970-2017. Computer methods

and programs in biomedicine. 2019:105075.

[81] N Van Eck, L Waltman. Software survey: VOSviewer, a

computer program for bibliometric mapping. scientometrics.

2010;84(2):523-38.

[82] NJ Van Eck, L Waltman. Visualizing bibliometric networks.

Measuring scholarly impact: Springer; 2014. p. 285-320.

[83] I Rafols, L Leydesdorff, A O’Hare, P Nightingale, A Stirling.

How journal rankings can suppress interdisciplinary research:

A comparison between innovation studies and business &

management. Research policy. 2012; 41(7):1262-82.

[84] J Northup, TR Vollmer, K Serrett. Publication trends in 25

years of the Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis. Journal of

Applied Behavior Analysis. 1993; 26(4):527-37.

[85] K McDonough, S Hutchinson, T Moore, JS Hutchinson.

Analysis of publication trends in ecosystem services research.

Ecosystem Services. 2017; 25:82-8.

[86] LR Halverson, CR Graham, KJ Spring, JS Drysdale. An

analysis of high impact scholarship and publication trends in

blended learning. Distance Education. 2012; 33(3):381-413.

[87] HT Reis, J Stiller. Publication trends in JPSP: A three-decade

review. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin. 1992;

18(4):465-72.

[88] C Walter, V Ribière. A citation and co-citation analysis of 10

years of KM theory and practices. Knowledge Management

Research & Practice. 2013; 11(3):221-9.

[89] J Arbaugh, A Hwang. What are the 100 most cited articles in

business and management education research, and what do

they tell us? Organization Management Journal. 2015;

12(3):154-75.

[90] DR May, MT Luth, CE Schwoerer. The influence of business

ethics education on moral efficacy, moral meaningfulness,

and moral courage: A quasi-experimental study. Journal of

Business Ethics. 2014; 124(1):67-80.

[91] TC Bergstrom, PN Courant, RP McAfee, MA Williams.

Evaluating big deal journal bundles. Proceedings of the

National Academy of Sciences. 2014; 111(26):9425-30.

[92] KL Strieb, JC Blixrud. Unwrapping the Bundle: An

Examination of Research Libraries and the" Big Deal". portal:

Libraries and the Academy. 2014; 14(4):587-615.

[93] Z Liu, Y Yin, W Liu, M Dunford. Visualizing the intellectual

structure and evolution of innovation systems research: a

bibliometric analysis. Scientometrics. 2015; 103(1):135-58.

[94] NJ Van Eck, L Waltman. Citation-based clustering of

publications using CitNetExplorer and VOSviewer.

Scientometrics. 2017; 111(2):1053-70.