Inclusive Knowledge Commons: MIT Open Scholarship, UNESCO Open Science, the UN SDGs, and Chattampi Swamikal’s Vision in Comparative Perspective

De Robbio, Antonella, Chithra, J S, Raman Nair, R and Amrith, M Inclusive Knowledge Commons: MIT Open Scholarship, UNESCO Open Science, the UN SDGs, and Chattampi Swamikal’s Vision in Comparative Perspective. Informatics Studies 12 (4), October - December, 2025, 2025, vol. 12, n. 4, pp. 17-36. [Journal article (Paginated)]

[thumbnail of IS 12 (4) 03 Antonella.pdf]
Preview
 Text
IS 12 (4) 03 Antonella.pdf - Published version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (293kB) | Preview

English abstract

Examines debates on open access and open science through a comparative historical lens, bringing into dialogue MIT’s Open Scholarship framework, UNESCO’s Open Science agenda aligned with the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), and the work of Chattampi Swamikal (1853–1924), a key intellectual figure of the Kerala Renaissance. While earlier debates on open scholarship emphasized technical, institutional, and economic challenges within a digital research ecosystem, recent discourse increasingly foregrounds inclusivity, linguistic diversity, community engagement, and knowledge as a global public good. The paper argues that the ethical assumptions underlying these contemporary frameworks have a striking antecedent in Swamikal’s late-nineteenth-century insistence on the social responsibility of knowledge. Drawing on his writings and pedagogical interventions - particularly his commitment to vernacular education, critique of caste-based monopolies over learning, and advocacy of public dissemination - the study interprets open access, open science, and open knowledge as modern institutional expressions of an earlier emancipatory epistemology. Based on this analysis, the paper proposes policy recommendations for an inclusive knowledge commons that integrates infrastructure, governance, incentives, linguistic accessibility, and ethical engagement. It concludes that sustainable and equitable open access requires not only technological infrastructure and policy reform, but also an ethical reorientation toward knowledge as a shared civilizational trust - a principle articulated with remarkable clarity in Chattampi Swamikal’s vision more than a century ago.

Item type: Journal article (Paginated)
Keywords: Open Access, Open Science, Knowledge Commons, Unesco, MIT, Chattampi Swamikal, SDGs, Epistemic Justice, Vernacular Scholarship
Subjects: E. Publishing and legal issues. > ED. Intellectual property: author's rights, ownership, copyright, copyleft, open access.
Depositing user: Antonella De Robbio
Date deposited: 12 Jan 2026 12:57
Last modified: 12 Jan 2026 12:57
URI: http://hdl.handle.net/10760/47583

References

Achuthsankar S. Nair (2024). Chattampi Swamikal, Viewed Through Modern Discourses on Knowledge and Freedom. Informatics Studies, Volume: 11, Issue 2. April-June, 2024

Achuthsankar S. Nair (2025). Democratisation of Knowledge: A Modern Concern and Historical Issue. Informatics Studies, Volume 12, Issue 1, January - March 2025

Ananda Wood (2025). Historical Dimensions of Knowledge Access and Dissemination in India. Informatics Studies, Volume 12, Issue 1, January - March 2025

Berlin Declaration (2023). Open Access to Knowledge in the Sciences and Humanities (2003).

Bhaskara Pillai, K (1960). Chattampi Swamikal. Kottayam, SPCS, 1960.

Brand, Amy and Sharp, Phillip A (2023) and the MIT Working Group on the Future of Research Publishing, Access to Science and Scholarship: Key Questions about the Future of Research Publishing (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2023), https://access-to-science.pubpub.org/pub/zqofn5h5.

Chattampi Swami (1890). Vedadikara Niroopanam. Kottayam, First collected together an published as printed book in 1909. Right to Learn Vedas: A Critique. Translated into English by Jagathsimhan Nair. Trivandrum, Chattampi Swami Archive, 2024.

Chattampi Swami (1895). Nijananda Vilasam. First printed by Varkala, Narayana Gurukulam, 1980.

Chattampi Swami (1903). Adhi Bhasha. First published with a study by K Maheswaran Nair from Trivandrum, Swantham Books, 1998.

Chattampi Swami (1909). Jeevakarunya Nirupanam. Vazhoor, First serialized in M N Nayar magazine in 1935. Compassion : A Crittique. Translated into English by Jagathsimhan Nair. Trivandrum, Chattampi Swami Archive, 2024.

Chattampi Swami (1910). Pracheena Malayalam. All available Volumes were compiled and published by a study with Pushpalatha. Trivandrum, Chattampi Swami Archive. Ancient Land of Malayalam. Translated into English by Jagathsimhan Nair. Trivandrum, Chattampi Swami Archive, 2024.

Chattampi Swami (1915). Advaitachintapaddhati. Reprint. Reprinted with a study by L Sulochana Devi. Englsh Translation by Thomas Goldenberg. Trivandrum, Chattampi Swami Archive in 2023.

Chattampi Swami (1917). Christumatha Chethanam. Reprinted with a study by R. Raman Nair Trivandrum, Chattampi Swami Archive in 2023.

Chattampi Swami (1920). Prapanchathil Stree Purushanmarkulla Sthanam. Reprinted with a study by L Sulochana Devi. Trivandrum, Chattampi Swami Archive in 2023. English Tr. Role of Man and Woman in the Cosmic Design. Translated into English by Jagathsimhan Nair. Trivandrum, Chattampi Swami Archive, 2024.

Chattampi Swamikal (1889). Christhumatha Saram. Quintessence of Christianity. Translated into English by Paulachan Kochappilly . Trivandrum, Chattampi Swami Archive, 2024.

Chattampi Swamikal (1890). Vedadhikara Nirupanam [Right to Study the Vedas]. Reprinted with a study by Vaikkam Vivekanandhan. Right to Learn Vedas: A Critique. Translated into English by Jagathsimhan Nair. Trivandrum, Chattampi Swami Archive, 2024. Trivandrum, Chattampi Swami Archive in 2023.

Chattampi Swamikal (1895). Christhumatha Nirupanam. Text of speeches were collected together and printed in 1930. Critique of Christianity. Translated into English by Richard Hay . Trivandrum, Chattampi Swami Archive, 2024.

Chattampi Swamikal (1897) Vedanta Saram. (Quintessence of Vedanta). Trivandrum, Chattampi Swami Archive, 2024.

Chithra J S and Vasudevan D M (2025). Ecocentrism and Open Knowledge: A Unified Vision for Food, Health, and Environment from Traditional Wisdom

Dilip Menon (2001). Arguing identity: Chattampi Swamikal and the Modern Nair Self. Proceedings of the National Seminar on Rethinking Modernity. Kalady Sree Sankara University of Sanskrit, November 2001

Dilip Menon (2010). Hindu, Christian, and Buddhist in a Non-Brahmin Space: South Indian Debates on Religion, 1900-1930. New Delhi, Delhi University.

Eve, Martin Paul (2012). Open Access, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press / MIT Press.

Gopinathan Pillai (2024). Vedadhikara Nirupanam : An Overview of Content and Purpose. Informatics Studies, Volume: 11, Issue 2. April-June, 2024

Govinda Pillai, P (2017) Kerala Nnavothanam, 5 Volumes. Trivandrum, Chintha. & The Kerala Renaissance: Knowledge, Reform, and Social Change. Thiruvananthapuram: Kerala Historical Society, 2018.

Harikrishnan Haridas (2024). Methodology of Chattampi Swamikal for Refuting the Laws to Monopolise Access to Knowledge. Informatics Studies, Volume: 11, Issue 2. April-June, 2024

Hay, Richard (2025). Christhumatha Nirupanam: Open Biblical Knowledge for Empirical Reflection. Informatics Studies, Volume 12 Issue 1, January - March 2025

Jagathsimhan Nair, S (2024). Dissemination of Knowledge in the Context of Chattampi Swamikal's Vedadhikara Nirupanam . Informatics Studies, Volume: 11, Issue 2. April-June, 2024

Jane Bakker and Nayana Nair (2024). The Vedas: Repository of Knowledge - A Societal Endeavor Beyond Class Boundaries. Informatics Studies, Volume: 11, Issue 2. April-June, 2024

Jayapradeep M (2023). Liberating Access to Knowledge, Validation, and Rights in Nineteenth Century India. Informatics Studies, Volume: 11, Issue 2. April-June, 2024

Jeffrey, Robin (1976). Societies and Politics in Travancore, 1847-1908. Sussex, Sussex University Press, 1976.

Kannudaya Vallalar (1851). Ozhivil Odukkam. Translated into Malayalam by Chattampi Swamikal. Trivandrum, Chattampi Swami Archive, 2017.

Karunakara Menon, K P (1967). Sri. Chattampi Swami: The Great Scholar-Saint of Kerala. Trivandrum, PGNP, 1967.

Maheswaran Nair, K (1967). Chattampi Swami: Jeevitavum Krithikalum. Trivandrum, Dooma Books, 1995.

Miedema, Frank (2021). Open Science: the Very Idea, Dordrecht, Springer.

MIT Press. (2023). Access to science and scholarship: Key questions about the future of research publishing. MIT Ad Hoc Task Force on Open Access. https://dspace.mit.edu/handle/1721.1/152414

Montgomery, Lucy; Hartley, John; Neylon, Cameron; Gillies, Malcolm; Gray, Eve et al. (2018). Open Knowledge Institutions: Reinventing Universities, Cambridge, MA, The MIT Press

Muthulekshmi K (2025). Chattampi Swamikal and Open Knowledge in Medical Sciences in Ninteenth Century South India . Informatics Studies, Volume 12 Issue 1, January - March 2025

Namputhiripad, E M S (1977). Caste, Classes and Parties in Modern Political Development with Special Reference to Kerala. In Proceedings of the World Malayalam Conference. Trivandrum, KU, 1977.

Narendra Bhooshan, Acharya (1990). Commentary on Vedadikara Niroopanam of Chattampi Swami. Chengannoor, Nitya Bharathi, 1990.

Nielsen, Michael (2011). Reinventing Discovery: The New Era of Networked Science, Princeton, NJ, Princeton University Press.

Nosek, Brian A; Spies, Jeffrey R and Motyl, Matt (2012). Scientific Utopia: II. Restructuring incentives and practices to promote truth over publishability. perspectives of Physchological Science, 7 (6) 7 November 2022'

Ostrom, Elinor (1990). Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990).

Paulachan Kochappilly (2025). The Open Knowledge Vision of Chattampi Swamikal's Christumatha Saram. Informatics Studies, Volume 12 Issue 1, January - March 2025

Pinfield, Stephen (2024). Achieving Global Open Access, Abingdon, Routledge.

Powell, Kendall (2020). Tech tools to make research more open and inclusive. Nature. 578 (7793). 3 February, 2020.

Praseetha Gireesh (2025). Chattampi Swami Studies: A Bibliometric Analysis of the Intellectual Spectrum of the Scholar Saint. Informatics Studies, Volume: 11, Issue 2. April-June, 2024

Raman Menon G (2024). Preface. Republished in ‘Right to Learn Vedas: A Critique’ by Chattampi Swamikal. Translated into English by Jagathsimhan Nair. Trivandrum, Chattampi Swami Archive, 2024.

Raman Nair and Sulochana Devi (2020). Charttampi Swami: An Intellectual Biography. Trivandrum, Centre for South Indian Studies, 2010.

Raman Nair R (2025). Earliest Attempt on Deconstruction of the Authority to Knowledge. Informatics Studies, Volume 12 Issue 1, January - March 2025

SPARC (2024). SPARC Open Access Newsletter. https://sparcopen.org/category/news/

Sreenathan M (2025). The Unheeded Dravidian Linguist Who Deconstructed the Brahmanical Knowledge Autonomy. Informatics Studies, Volume 12 Issue 1, January - March 2025

Suber, Peter (2004). Open Access Overview: Focusing on open access to peer-reviewed research articles and their preprints. http://legacy.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/overview.htm

Suber, Peter (2009). Knowledge as a public good. https://dash.harvard.edu/handle/1/4391171

Suber, Peter (2016). Knowledge Unbound: Selected Writings on Open Access, 2002-2011. Massachusetts, The MIT Press.

Suber, Peter. Adapted from Writings of (2024). Open Access Initiatives: Bridging Knowledge to the Public Domain . Informatics Studies, Volume: 11, Issue 2. April-June, 2024

Sulochana Devi L (2025). Chattampi Swamikal: The Scholar Saint Who Integrated Knowledge and Spirituality in Social and Political Process . New Delhi, UGC Research Project.

Sulochana Devi, L (1998). Chattampi Swami's Concept of Vedic Authority and Reformation in Kerala. In the Proceedings of the South Indian History Congress. XVIII Session. Kalady, SSUS, 1998

Sulochana Devi, L. Social Philosophy of Chattampi Swami. In: Studies on Culture, Science and Literature. Madras, SSES Research Centre, 2000.

Sundara Swamikal, Kodakanallur (1880) Nijanandha Vilasam. Translated into Malayalam by Chattampi Swamikal. First printed by Varkala, Narayana Gurukulam, 1980. CSA Edition: Trivandrum, Chattampi Swami Archive, 2021.

Suresh Madhav (2025). Empowering at Grassroots Level Through Knowledge Sharing in Nineteenth Century Kerala. Informatics Studies, Volume 12 Issue 1, January - March 2025.

Tomy Varghese (2024). Open Access to Research: A Paradigm Shift in Indian Context. Informatics Studies, Volume: 11, Issue 2. April-June, 2024

UNESCO (2023). UNESCO Recommendation on Open Science. https://www.UNESCO.it/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/RECOMMENDATION-ON-OPEN-SCIENCE-2021-Certified.pdf

United Nations (2015). Transforming Our World: The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development . New York: United Nations, 2015.

Unnikrishnan A M (2024). Chattampi Swamikal and the Democratisation of Knowledge. Informatics Studies, Volume: 11, Issue 2. April-June, 2024

Vivekanandan, Vaikkam (2007). Vedhadikaram Arkokke? (Who has the right to study and teach Vedas?. Ambaprasadam. August-September 2007.

Vivekanandan, Vaikkam (2009). Pracheena Malayalam Randam Pusthkam: Oru Nireekshanakurippu. Chattampi Swami Archives, 2009


Downloads

Downloads per month over past year

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item
Contact us
Send email Sponsors
Sponsor: AIMS Sponsor: D&P Sponsor: UniNa CAB Get connected
Facebook Facebook Twitter Twitter Linkedin LinkedIn RSS RSS