Using local citation data to relate the use of journal articles by academic researchers to the coverage of full-text document access systems

Jacobs, Neil, Woodfield, Julie and Morris, Anne Using local citation data to relate the use of journal articles by academic researchers to the coverage of full-text document access systems. Journal of Documentation, 2000, vol. 56, n. 4, pp. 563-581. [Journal article (Paginated)]

[thumbnail of Citanal.pdf]
Preview
PDF
Citanal.pdf

Download (123kB) | Preview

English abstract

The methodology and findings are presented of an empirical study comparing local citation patterns with the holdings lists of a number of sources of journal articles. These sources were the British Library Document Supply Centre (BLDSC) and the BL 'inside' service, library holdings, ProQuest Direct, SearchBank, EiText and a linking system including both the Geobase database and the BLDSC. The value of local citation figures is discussed, as is the concept of a 'core' of journal titles, from both theoretical and practical perspectives. Using these figures to represent the local use of journal articles, the coverage of the document sources was found to vary widely. Unsurprisingly, the BLDSC was found to offer the widest coverage. Newer, electronic systems generally fared less well, but may offer other advantages.

Item type: Journal article (Paginated)
Keywords: citation analysis, bibliometrics, usage data, journals, demand
Subjects: D. Libraries as physical collections. > DD. Academic libraries.
J. Technical services in libraries, archives, museum. > JJ. Document delivery.
B. Information use and sociology of information > BB. Bibliometric methods
Depositing user: Neil Jacobs
Date deposited: 01 Nov 2005
Last modified: 02 Oct 2014 12:01
URI: http://hdl.handle.net/10760/6809

References

The FIDDO homepage is: http://www.lboro.ac.uk/departments/dis/fiddo/fiddo.html (visited 13 January 2000)

Line, M.B. Draft definitions: information and library needs, wants, demands and uses. Aslib Proceedings, 26 (2), 1974, 87.

Woolgar, S. Beyond the citation debate: towards a sociology of measurement technologies and their use in science policy. Science and Public Policy, 18 (5), 1991, 319-326.

Line, M.B. Use of citation data for periodicals control in libraries: a response to Broadus. College and Research Libraries, 46 (1), 1985, 36-37.

Horwill, C. and Lambert, P. 1 man - 100 votes: a new approach to reviewing periodicals subscriptions at the University of Sussex. Aslib Proceedings, 39 (1), 1987, 7-16.

Greene, R.J. Computer analysis of local citation information in collection management. Collection Management, 17 (4), 1993, 11-24.

Hurd, J.M., Blecic, D.D. and Vishwanathan, R. Information use by molecular biologists: implications for library collections and services. College and Research Libraries, 60 (1), 1999, 31-43.

Broadus, R.N. A proposed method for eliminating titles from periodical subscription lists. College and Research Libraries, 46 (1), 1985, 30-35.

Hoadley, I.B. Access vs ownership: myth or reality. Library Acquisitions: Practice and Theory, 17, 1993, 191-195.

Brin, B. and Cochran, E. Access and ownership in the academic environment: one library's progress report. Journal of Academic Librarianship, 20 (4), 1994, 207-212.

Line, M.B. Changes in rank lists of serials over time: interlending versus citation data. College and Research Libraries, 46 (1), 1985, 77-80.

Zipp, L.S. Core serial titles in an interdisciplinary field: the case of environmental geology. Library Resources and Technical Services, 43 (1), 1999, 28-36.

Johnson, W.T. Environmental impact: a preliminary citation analysis for local faculty in a new academic program in environmental and human health applied to collection development at Texas Tech University Library. Library and Information Science Research, 9 (1), 1999. Available at: http://aztec.lib.utk.edu/libres/libre9n1/toxcite.htm (visited 13 January 2000)

Walcott, R. Local citation studies: a shortcut to local knowledge. Science and Technology Libraries, 14 (3), 1994, 1-14.

Kreider, J. The correlation of local citation data with citation data from Journal Citation Reports. Library Resources and Technical Services, 43 (2), 1999, 67-77.

Line, M.B. Use of citation data for periodicals control in libraries: a response to Broadus. College and Research Libraries, 46 (1), 1985, 36-37.

Dole, W.V. and Chang, S.S. Survey and analysis of demand for journals at the State University of New York at Stony Brook. Library Acquisitions: Practice and Theory, 20 (1), 1996, 23-38.

Hughes, J. Use of faculty publication lists and ISI citation data to identify a core list of journals with local importance. Library Acquisitions: Practice and Theory, 19 (4), 1995, 403-413.

Schmidt, D., Davis, E.B. and Jahr, R. Biology journal use at an academic library: a comparison of use studies. Serials Review, 20 (2), 1994, 45-64.

Swigger, K. and Wilkes, A. The use of citation data to evaluate serials subscriptions in an academic library. Serials Review, 17 (2), 1991, 41-46.

Kelland, J.L. and Young, A.P. Citation as a form of library use. Collection Management, 19 (1/2), 1994, 81-100.

Kelland, J.L and Young, A.P. Citation patterns and library use. In: Kent, A. ed. Encyclopaedia of Library and Information Science. Volume 61, 1998. New York: Marcel Dekker.

Osareh, F. Bibliometrics, citation analysis and co-citation analysis: a review of literature 1. Libri, 46, 1996, 149-158.

Cronin, B. The citation process. London: Taylor Graham, 1984.

MacRoberts, M.H. and MacRoberts, B.R. Problems of citation analysis. Scientometrics, 36 (3), 1996, 435-444.

Campbell, R. The publisher's position: survival in an electronic world. In: Cunningham, A.M. and Wicks, W. (eds) Changing roles in information distribution. Philadelphia, PA: National Federation of Abstracting and Information Services, 1993.

Pinfield, S. et al. Realizing the hybrid library. D-Lib Magazine, October 1998. Available at:

http://mirrored.ukoln.ac.uk/lis-journals/dlib/dlib/dlib/october98/10pinfield.html (visited 13 January 2000)

Oppenheim, C. and Smithson, D. What is the hybrid library? Journal of Information Science. 25 (2), 1999, 97-112.

Brookes, B.C. Bradford's Law and the bibliography of science. Nature, 224, 1969, 953-956.

McCain, K.W. Patterns of journal use in a departmental library: a citation analysis. Journal of the American Society for Information Science. 32 (4) 1981, 257-267.

Udofia. U.I. Selecting veterinary medical periodicals through citation analysis. Library Review, 46 (2), 1997, 105-112.

Depew, J.N. and Basu, S. The application of Bradford's Law in selecting periodicals on conservation and preservation of library materials. Collection Management, 8 (1), 1986, 55-64.

White, H.D. and McCain, K.W. Bibliometrics. In: Annual Review of Information Science and Technology, 24, 1989, 119-186.

Rousseau, R. The nuclear zone of a Leimkuhler curve. Journal of Documentation, 43 (4), 1987, 322-333.

McCain, K.W. Core journal networks and cocitation maps: new bibliometric tools for serials research and management. Library Quarterly, 61 (3), 1991, 311-336.

White, H.D. and McCain, K.W. Bibliometrics. In: Annual Review of Information Science and Technology, 24, 1989, 119-186.

Brookes, B.C. Bradford's Law and the bibliography of science. Nature, 224, 1969, 953-956.

Rousseau, R. and Leimkuhler, F.F. The nuclear zone of a Leimkuhler curve. Journal of Documentation, 43 (4), 1987, 322-333.

Goffman, W and Warren, K.S. Dispersion of papers among journals based on a mathematical anlaysis of two diverse medical literatures. Nature 221, 1969, 1205-1207.

Gillaspy, M.L. and Huber, J.T. The literature of women and the Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome (AIDS): implications for collection development and information retrieval. Medical Reference Services Quarterly, 15 (4), 1996, 21-39.

Brooks, T.A. Core journals of the rapidly changing research front of 'superconductivity'. In Borgman, C. (ed). Scholarly communication and bibliometrics. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications, 1990.

FIDDO. Document delivery in a dynamic hybrid environment. Final report to the Electronic Libraries Programme. 1999.

SuperJournal. Summary of SuperJournal findings. 1999. Available at: http://www.superjournal.ac.uk/sj (visited 13 January 2000)

Anderson, M. Report of the Group on National/Regional Strategy for Library Provision for Researchers, report to Funding Councils (the Anderson Report). 1995. Available at: http://www.ukoln.ac.uk/services/elib/papers/other/anderson/ (visited 13 January 2000)

See the FIDDO homepage, at: http://www.lboro.ac.uk/departments/dis/fiddo/fiddo.html (visited 13 January 2000)

Crotteau, M. Support for biological research by an academic library: a journal citation study. Science and Technology Libraries, 17 (1), 1997, 67-86.

Pat Wressel and Associates Library service provision for researchers. Proceedings of the Anderson Report Seminar organized by the Library and Information Co-operation Council and the Standing Conference of National and University Libraries. Bruton: LINC, 1997.

Stankus, T. and Rice, B. Handle with care: use and citation data for science journal management. Collection Management, 4 (1/2), 1982, 95-110.

BLDSC services are described at: http://www.bl.uk/services/bsds/dsc/ (visited 13 January 2000)

The BL inside service is described at: http://www.bl.uk/online/inside/ (visited 13 January 2000)

ProQuest Direct, now ProQuest, is described at: http://www.umi.com/proquest/ (visited 13 January 2000)

SearchBank, now InfoTrac, is described at: http://www.galegroup.com (visited 13 January 2000)

SilverLinker is described at the SilverPlatter site: http://www.silverplatter.com/ (visited 13 January 2000)

EiText is described at the Engineering Information site: http://www.ei.org/ (visited 13 January 2000)

British Library. Facts and figures 1999. http://www.bl.uk/services/bsds/dsc/pdf_files/factnfig.pdf (visited 13 January 2000)

Line, M. Changes in rank lists of serials over time: interlending versus citation data. College and Research Libraries, 46 (1), 1985, 77-80.

The Lamda service is described at: http://lamdaweb.mcc.ac.uk/ (visited 13 January 2000)

Anderson, M. Access to research collections in the UK: the Anderson Report updated. Library Review, 13 (4), 1998, 262-266.

Jacobs, N. et al. Planning document access: options and opportunities. London: Bowker Saur (forthcoming).

Morris, A., Woodfield, J. and Davies, J.E. Experimental evaluation of selected electronic document delivery systems. Journal of Library and Information Science, 31 (3), 1999, 135-144.


Downloads

Downloads per month over past year

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item