Quality of academic libraries - funding bodies, librarians and users perspective: a common project of Polish research libraries on comparable measures

Derfert-Wolf, Lidia and Górski, Marek M. and Marcinek, Marzena Quality of academic libraries - funding bodies, librarians and users perspective: a common project of Polish research libraries on comparable measures., 2005 . In IFLA Council and General Conference (71st : 2005 : Oslo), Oslo (Norway), 14th - 18th August 2005. (Unpublished) [Conference paper]


Download (278kB) | Preview

English abstract

According to the ISO Standard 11620 Performance Indicators for Libraries, the quality means "totality of features and characteristics of a product or services that bear on the library's ability to satisfy stated or implied needs". Hence the quality assessment depends not only on the product or service as it is but also on a person or institution involved in the assessment process. High quality of library performance is crucial for each research library to survive. Wide on-line access to information makes researchers and students demand the highest quality library services. It is the quality of library services that decides on the perception of the library within its parent institution and the society. Comparable quality measures (which refer not only to library services but to all aspects of library performance) are of vital importance for efficient and effective library management. A library needs both to satisfy its users and to prove to its funding bodies that it is worth investment. Moreover, the State Accreditation Commission in the process of the assessment of higher education institutions takes the quality of library services into account. Therefore current efforts to determine unified standards and library performance indicators are a starting point to the full implementation of reliable analysis-based management and assessment. The main objective of the paper is to present the results of the on-going study of performance indicators for Polish research libraries. The report from the research together with background information on library statistical data collection reflects the overall situation of library quality measures and assessment in Poland. The study is a continuation of the activity realised in the frame of the EU Tempus Project "Development of Library Management as a Part of the University Total Quality Management". The Group for Standardisation presently conducts the research in the frame of the national project financed from the funds of the Ministry of National Education and Sport. Authors of the research encountered many difficulties implied by the lack of national patterns or standards for library statistics and effectiveness measurement to follow. Therefore they have been trying to adopt model foreign solutions to the Polish realities. The paper describes the tools for library performance evaluation applied in Poland in 2003. The authors discuss some issues related to the preparation of an online questionnaire for comparative studies and a computer program for a quantitative and qualitative data collection and analysis. Next, the results of the research for the years 2002-2003 are presented including tables and graphs. Finally, we present a proposal for new standard surveys to be used for the assessment of the quality of libraries by their users (according to the international standard 11620). Data received from users surveys will provide important complementary information to the raw data and the indicators derived from them.

Item type: Conference paper
Keywords: university libraries, library statistics, performance measurement, performance indicatirs, quality, Poland
Subjects: D. Libraries as physical collections. > DD. Academic libraries.
F. Management. > FA. Co-operation.
F. Management. > FZ. None of these, but in this section.
F. Management. > FC. Finance.
F. Management. > FF. Funding.
Depositing user: Lidia Derfert-Wolf
Date deposited: 06 Nov 2005
Last modified: 02 Oct 2014 12:02
URI: http://hdl.handle.net/10760/6831


ACRL Board of Directors (2004), ACRL Standards for Libraries in Higher Education. Available at: http://www.ala.org/ala/acrl/acrlstandards/standardslibraries.htm, [accessed on 20.05.05].

Altman, E. and Hernon, P. (1998), Service quality and customer satisfaction do matter. American Libraries, August 53-54.

Ambrožič, M. (2003), A few countries measure impact and outcomes – most would like to measure at least something. Performance Measurement and Metrics, Vol. 4, No 2., 64-78.

Barnard, S. B. (1994), Total quality management: customer-centered models for libraries. In: Total Quality Management in Libraries. A Sourcebook, Englewood 1994, 1-4.

Blixrud, J. C. (2001), The Association of Research Libraries Statistics and Measurement Program: From descriptive data to performance measurement. IN: 67th IFLA Council and General Conference. August 16-25, 2001. Available at: http://www.ifla.org/IV/ifla67/papers/034-135e.pdf [accessed 20.05.05].

Brophy, P. (2004), The Quality of libraries. In Die effective Bibliothek. Hilgermann, K. and te Borkhorst, P.(eds.) München: K. G. Saur. 30-46.

Buzdygan, D., Różycka, M., Sobielga, J., Tomczak, E. (2000), Survey of users needs using LIBRA software. In: Quality management in academic libraries. International conference held in Bydgoszcz - Gniew, 10-13 September 2000. EBIB Conference Proceedings, Polish Librarian Association, Available at:http://ebib.oss.wroc.pl/matkonf/atr/buzdyg_abs.html, [accessed on 20.05.05].

Derfert-Wolf, L. and Bednarek-Michalska B. [eds.], (2000), Quality management in academic libraries. International conference held in Bydgoszcz - Gniew, 10-13 September 2000. In: EBIB Conference Proceedings Available at: http://ebib.oss.wroc.pl/matkonf/atr/indexen.html, [accessed 20.05.05].

Derfert-Wolf, L., Dobrzyńska-Lankosz, E., Dziadkiewicz, W., Górny, M., Górska, E., Górski, M., Jazdon, A., Sokołowska-Gogut, A. and Wildhardt, T. (2003), Performance indicators and standards for Polish research libraries. Library & Information Research, vol. 27, no 87, 17-28.

Derfert-Wolf, L., Górski M., Marzena M. (2004), Management based on reliable comparative data. Library statistics and performance indicators. A common project of Polish research libraries. In: 25 Annual IATUL Conference "Library Management in Changing Environment. May 30 - June 3, 2004, Kraków. Available at:http://www.iatul.org/conference/proceedings/vol14/fulltexts/Lidia%20Derfert-Wolf_Marek%20M.Gorski_Marzena%20Marcinek.pdf, [accessed on 20.05.05].

Franklin, B. and Nitecki, D. (1999), User satisfaction white paper. Washington, DC: Association of Research Libraries. Available at: http://www.arl.org/libqual/geninfo/usersatisfaction.pdf , [accessed 20.05.05].

Górny, M, Jazdon A. (1997), The Implementation of Information Technology Projects in Polish Research and Academic Libraries in the early 1990 s. Questions of Scope and Effectiveness. Library Management, Vol. 18, No. 6, 280-285.

Górny, M., Jazdon A., Nowak P., (1999), Selected Indicators of the Range and Use Printed Resources in Polish Academic Libraries. Library Management, Vol.20, No. 3/4, 159-167.

Hernon, P.(1996), Numbers, numbers. Journal of Academic Librarianship, Vol. 22, Issue 4, 249-250.

Hernon, P., Nitecki D., Altman, E. (1999), Service quality and customer satisfaction; an assessment and future directions. Journal of Academic Librarianship, Vol. 25, Issue 1, 9-17.

ISO 11620 (1998), ISO 11620: 1998/AD1: 2003 Information and Documentation. Library performance indicators.

ISO 2789 (2003), Information and documentation. International library statistics.

Jazdon, A. (2002), On evaluation and categorization of libraries. In: EBIB Electronic Information Bulletin for Librarians. No 2. Available at: http://ebib.oss.wroc.pl/english/grant/jazdon.php, [accessed on 20.05.05].

Joint Funding Councils' Ad-hoc Working Group on Performance Indicators for Libraries (1995), The Effective Academic Library: A Framework for Evaluating the Performance of UK Academic Libraries. London: HEFCE.

Klug, P. (2003), Setting Benchmarks with BIX – the German Library Index. In: World Library and Information Congress: 69th IFLA General Conference and Council, 1-9 August 2003, Berlin, Available at: http://www.ifla.org/IV/ifla69/papers/138g-Klug.pdf, [accessed on 20.05.05].

Kyrillidou, M., Blixrud, J. (1998), Measuring The Changing Library Environment. ARL Statistics and Measurement Program. Available at: http://www.arl.org/stats/arlstat/context98.html, [accessed 20.05.05].

Laeven, H., Smit, A. (2003), A project to benchmark university libraries in the Netherlands. Library Management Vol. 24, No 6/7, 291-304.

Mowat, I. R. M. (1996), Ensuring quality staff in a modern university library. In: Library Management and Information Technology. Proceedings of the seminar held in Vilnius, Lithuania, 27-33.

Nitecki, D. (1996), Changing the concept and measure of service quality in academic libraries. Journal of Academic Librarianship, Vol. 22, Issue 3, 181-190.

Osiewalski, J., Osiewalska, A. (2004), Measuring cost efficiency of public and academic libraries in Poland - a methodological perspective and empirical experience. In: 25 Annual IATUL Conference "Library Management in Changing Environment. May 30 - June 3, Kraków. Available at:http://www.iatul.org/conference/proceedings/vol14/fulltexts/Anna%20i%20Jacek%20Osiewalscy.pdf,[accessed 20.05.05].

Osman, Z., Goon, C. A., Aris, W. H. W. (1998), Quality services: policies and practices in Malaysia. Library Management, Vol. 19, No 7, 426 - 433.

Owens, I., Anghelescu, H. G. B. (1999), Plowing in Rocky Land: Organizational Culture, Managed Change, and Quality Improvement in Selected Romanian Post-Communist Libraries. International Information & Library Review, Vol. 31, Issue 4, 197-224 .

Pindlowa, W. (2002), High-quality information services to users as the fundamental necessity for building a modern information society in the European Union. In: EBIB Electronic Information Bulletin for Librarians, No 2. Available at: http://ebib.oss.wroc.pl/english/grant/pindlowa.php, [accessed 20.05.05].

Poll, R. (2004). Quality. IFLA 2004 [presentation]. Available at: http://www.ulb.unimuenster.de/projekte/outcome/downloads/IFLA%202004-quality.ppt, [accessed 20.05.05].

Poll, R., te Boekhorst, P. (1996), Measuring quality : international guidelines for performance measurement in academic libraries. IFLA Publications 76. München.

Pritchard, S. M. (1996), Determining quality in academic libraries - Perspectives on Quality in Libraries. Library Trends, Vol. 44, Issue 3, 572-594.

Sokołowska-Gogut, A. [ed], (2001), Badania porównawcze polskich bibliotek naukowych. Materiały z konferencji (Kraków, 19-21 września 2001). Kraków.

Ward, S. Sumsion, J., Fuegi, D., Bloor, I. (1995), Library Performance Indicators and Library Management Tools. Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities.

Whitehall, T. (1994), Quality in library and information services: A Review. In: Total Quality Management in Libraries. A Sourcebook, Englewood, 100-121.

Wilson, A., Pitman, L., Trahn, I. (2000), Guidelines for the application of best practice in Australian University Libraries: Intranational and International Benchmarks. Available at: http://www.dest.gov.au/archive/highered/eippubs/eip00_11/00_11.pdf, [accessed 20.05.05].

Winkworth, I. (2001), Innovative United Kingdom approaches to measuring service quality. Library Trends, Vol. 49, Issue 4, 718-732.


Downloads per month over past year

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item