Scatter and Obsolescence of Journals Cited in Dissertations of Librarianship

Tonta, Yaşar and Al, Umut Scatter and Obsolescence of Journals Cited in Dissertations of Librarianship. Library & Information Science Research, 2006, vol. 28, n. 2, pp. 281-296. [Journal article (Paginated)]


Download (323kB) | Preview

English abstract

This article analyzes the bibliometric features (the number of pages, completion years, the fields of subject, the number of citations, and their distribution by types of sources and years) of 100 theses and dissertations completed at the Department of Librarianship of Hacettepe University between 1974 and 2002. Almost a quarter (24%) of all dissertations were on university libraries, followed by public libraries (9%). Doctoral dissertations were, on average, twice as long as master’s theses and contained 2.5 times more citations. Monographs received more citations (50%) than journal articles did (42%). Recently completed theses and dissertations contained more citations to electronic publications. Fourteen (or 3.2% of all) journal titles (including Türk Kütüphaneciliği, College & Research Libraries, and Journal of the American Society for Information Science) received almost half(48.9%) of all citations. Eighty percent of journal titles were cited infrequently. No correlation was found between the frequency of citations of the most frequently cited journals and their impact factors. Cited journal titles in master’s and doctoral theses and dissertations overlapped significantly. Similarly, journal titles cited in dissertations also overlapped significantly with those that were cited in the journal articles published in the professional literature. The distribution of citations to foreign journal titles fit Bradford’s Law of Scattering. The mean half-life of all cited sources was 9 years. Sources cited in master’s dissertations were relatively more current. Single authorship was the norm in cited resources. Coupled with in-library use data, findings of the present study can be used to identify the core journal titles in librarianship as well as to evaluate the existing library collections to decide which journal titles to keep, discard, or relegate to off-site storage areas.

Item type: Journal article (Paginated)
Keywords: Journal scatter, journal obsolescence, theses, dissertations, bibliometrics
Subjects: B. Information use and sociology of information > BB. Bibliometric methods
Depositing user: prof. yasar tonta
Date deposited: 06 May 2007
Last modified: 02 Oct 2014 12:07


"SEEK" links will first look for possible matches inside E-LIS and query Google Scholar if no results are found.

Al, U., & Tonta, Y. (2004). Atıf analizi: Hacettepe Üniversitesi Kütüphanecilik Bölümü tezlerinde atıf yapılan kaynaklar [Citation analysis: Cited sources in dissertations completed at the Department of Library Science, Hacettepe University]. Bilgi Dünyası, 5, 19–47.

Alkan, N. (1998). Temel ve uygulamalı bilim dallarında etki faktörü değeri en yüksek olan sü reli yayınların Ankara’daki üniversite kütüphanelerinde bulunabilirliği [Journals with the highest impact factors in pure and applied sciences and their aıailability in uniıersity libraries in Ankara]. Türk Kütüphaneciliği, 12, 279–305.

Alkan, N. (1999). Tıp ve sağlık bilimleri dallarının 1990’larda etki faktörü değeri en yüksek olan süreli yayınları ve bunların Ankara’daki ilgili kütüphanelerde bulunabilirliği Journals with the highest impact factors in medical and health sciences in 1990s and their availability in libraries in Ankara]. Bilginin Serüveni: Dünü ,bugünü ve yarını . . . [Adventure of information: Its past, present and future. . .] (pp. 278–300). Ankara Türk Kütüphaneciler Derneği.

Bayram, Ö . (Gökkurt) (1998). Atıf verisi (citation data) ve enformetrik yasalar: Türk kütüphanecilik literatüründeki doktora tezleri üzerinde bir uygulama [Citation data and informetrics laws: An application to doctoral theses in Turkish librarianship]. Türk Kütüphaneciliği, 12, 21–32.

Bradford, S. C. (1934). Sources of information on specific subjects. Engineering, 137, 85–86.

Buttlar, L. (1999). Information sources in library and information science doctoral research. Library & Information Science Research, 21, 227–245.

Denkel, A., Kağıtçıbaşı, Ç., Pak, N. K., & Pamuk, X. (1999). Türkiye’de sosyal bilimlerin uluslararası yayın performansı [International publication performance of Turkey in social sciences]. Ankara Türkiye Bilimler Akademisi.

Earle, P., & Iickery, B. (1969). Social science literature use in the UK as indicated by citations. Journal of Documentation, 25, 123–141.

Edwards, S. (1999). Citation analysis as a collection development tool: A bibliometric study of polymer science theses and dissertations. Serials Review, 25, 11–20.

Garfield, E. (1980). Bradford’s Law and related statistical patterns. Current Contents, 19, 5–12. Retrieved January 10, 2004 fromı4p476y1979-80.pdf

Gooden, A. M. (2001). Citation analysis of chemistry doctoral dissertations: An Ohio State University case study. Issues in Science & Technology Librarianship, 32. Retrieved January 10, 2004 from

Gökkurt, Ö . (1997a). CitationQ indeks ve citationT analizi: Enformetrik bir model çalışması [Citation index and citation analysis: A study of an informetric model]. Unpublished PhD dissertation. Ankara Uniıersity, Ankara.

Gökkurt, Ö . (1997b). Yoğunlaşma teorisi ve atıf analizinde kullanımı [Concentration theory and its use in citation analysis]. Kütüphanecilik Bölümü 25. Yıla Armağan [A festschrift to honor the 25th anniıersary of the foundation of the Department of Librarianship, Hacettepe University] (pp. 153–161). Ankara Hacettepe Uniıersity.

Gülgöz, S., Yedekçioğlu, Ö . A., & Yurtseıer, E. (2002). Turkey’s output in social science publications: 1970–1999. Scientometrics, 55, 103–121.

Gürdal, O. (2002). Altın yılını yaşayan Türk Kütüphaneciliği dergisinden yansımalar [Reflections from the Journal of Turkish Librarianship in its golden year]. Türk Kütüphaneciliği, 16, 321–328.

Hertzel, D. H. (1987). Bibliometrics, history of the development of ideas in. In A. Kent (Ed.), Encyclopedia of library and information science, ıol. 42 (pp. 144–219). New York Marcel Dekker.

Herubel, J.-P. I. M. (1991). Philosophy dissertation bibliographies and citations in serials eıaluation. Serials Librarian, 20, 65–73.

ISI. (2002). Institute for Scientific Information. Journal Citation Reports. Retrieved September 21, 2003 from

Jacobson, A., Milman, A. D., & Kammen, D. M. (2004). Letting the (energy) Gini out of the bottle: Lorenz curıes of cumulatiıe electricity consumption and Gini coefficients as metrics of energy distribution and equity. Energy Policy. Retrieved November 20, 2004 from

Kum, I˙. (1974). Türkiye’de tıp kütüphaneleri [Medical libraries in Turkey]. Unpublished associate professorship dissertation. Hacettepe Uniıersity, Ankara.

Kurbanoğlu, S. S. (1996). Türk kütüphanecilerinin kullandığı dergiler [Journals cited by Turkish librarians]. Türk Kütüphaneciliğ i, 10, 105–118.

Kushkowski, J. D., Parsons, K. A., & Wiese, W. H. (2003). Master’s and doctoral thesis citations: Analysis and trends of a longitudinal study. Portal: Libraries and the Academy, 3, 459–479. Retrieved September 22, 2003 fromı003/3.3kushkowski.pdf

Kuyper-Rushing, L. (1999). Identifying uniform core journal titles for music libraries: A dissertation citation study. College & Research Libraries, 60, 153–163.

LaBorie, T., & Halperin, M. (1976). Citation patterns in library science dissertations. Journal of Education for Librarianship, 14, 271–283.

Line, M. B. (1970). The dhalf-lifeT of periodical literature: Apparent and real obsolescence. Journal of Documentation, 26, 46–54.

McCain, K. W., & Bobick, J. E. (1981). Patterns of journal use in a departmental library: A citation analysis. Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 32, 257–267.

Meadows, A. J. (1967). The citation characteristics of astronomical research literature. Journal of Documentation, 23, 28–33.

Rousseau, R. (1987, August, 25–28). Citation distribution of pure mathematics journals. In L. Egghe, & R.

Rousseau (Eds.), Informetrics 87/88: Select Proceedings of the First International Conference on Bibliometrics and Theoretical Aspects of Information Retrieıal, Diepenbeek, Belgium (pp. 249–262). Amsterdam7 Elsevier.

Rousseau, R. (1998). Eıenness as a descriptiıe parameter for department or faculty eıaluation studies. In E. De Smet (Ed.), Informatiewetenschap 1998 (pp. 135–145). Antwerp Werkgemeenschap Informatiewetenschap.ıen_conf.pdf

Rousseau, R. (2000, October 23–25). Concentration and eıenness measures as macro-leıel scientometric indicators. Paper presented at the Second International Seminar on Quantitatiıe Eıaluation of Research Performance-Shanghai. Retrieved Noıember 19, 2004 from

Sengupta, I. N. (1974). Impact of scientific periodicals on the adıancement of medical knowledge: An objectiıe method of analysis. International Library Review, 4, 169–195.

Smith, L. C. (1981). Citation analysis. Library Trends, 30, 83–106.

Sylıia, M., & Lesher, M. (1995). What journals do psychology graduate students need? A citation analysis of thesis references. College & Research Libraries, 56, 313–318.

Tonta, Y. (2000). Contribution of Turkish researchers to the world’s biomedical literature (1988–1997). Scientometrics, 48, 71–84.

Tonta, Y. (2002). Türk Kütüphaneciliğidergisi, 1987–2001 [The Journal of Turkish Librarianship, 1987–2001]. Türk Kütüphaneciliği, 16, 282–320.

Tonta, Y., & İlhan, M. (1997). Sosyal bilimlerde Türkiye’nin dünyadaki yeri [Turkey’s place in social sciences in the world]. Türk Psikoloji Dergisi, 12, 67–74.

Tonta, Y., & İlhan, M. (2002). Contribution of Hacettepe University Faculty of Medicine to the world’s biomedical literature (1988–1997). Scientometrics, 55, 123–136.

Trueswell, R. L. (1969). Some behaıioral patterns of library users: The 80/20 rule. Wilson Library Bulletin, 43, 458–461.

Walcott, R. (1991). Characteristics of citations in geoscience doctoral dissertations accepted at United States academic institutions 1981–1985. Science & Technology Libraries, 12(2), 5–16.

Walcott, R. (1994). Local citation studies: A shortcut to local knowledge. Science & Technology Libraries, 14(3), 1–14.

Waugh, C. K., & Ruppel, M. (2004). Citation analysis of dissertation, thesis, and research paper references in workforce education and deıelopment. Journal of Academic Librarianship, 30, 276–284.

White, E. C. (1985, Winter). Bibliometrics: From curiosity to conıention. Special Libraries, 76, 35–42.

Yurtsever, E., & Gülgöz, S. (1999). The increase in the rate of publications originating from Turkey. Scientometrics, 46, 321–336.

Yurtsever, E., Gülgöz, S., Yedekçioğlu, Ö . A., & Tonta, M. (2001). Sosyal Bilimler Atıf Dizini’nde (SSCI) Türkiye: 1970–1999 [Turkey in the Social Science Citation Index; 1970–1999]. Ankara Türkiye Bilimler Akademisi.

Yurtsever, E., Gülgöz, S., Yedekçioğlu, Ö . A., & Tonta, M. (2002). Sağlık bilimleri, mühendislik ve temel bilimlerde Türkiye’nin uluslararasI atıf dizinindeki yeri: 1973–1999 [Turkey’s place at international citation index in medical sciences, engineering and pure sciences; 1973–1999]. Ankara Türkiye Bilimler Akademisi.

Zipp, L. S. (1996). Thesis and dissertation citations as indicators of faculty research use of university library journal collections. Library Resources & Technical Services, 40, 335–342.

Actions (login required)

Edit Item Edit Item