E-LIS, Eprints in Library and Information Science Homepage E-LIS, Eprints in Library and Information Science
   home   |   about   |   search   |   browse   |   register   |   registered users area   |   help   |   FAQ   |   JITA   

Struggle against racial exclusion in public libraries: a fight for the rights of the people

Durrani, Shiraz (2000) Struggle against racial exclusion in public libraries: a fight for the rights of the people, in Muddiman, Dave, Eds. Open to All? : the Public Library and Social Exclusion, chapter 13, Vol.3, pp. 250-350. London: Resource: The Council for Museums, Archives and Libraries.

Full text available as:
PDF - Requires Adobe Acrobat Reader or other PDF viewer.

View statistics for this eprint

Abstract

This paper discusses racism in the UK, relating it to both social and economic exclusion, and to social class. Institutional racism is discussed, as is racism’s relation to wider global factors. The history of race relations in the UK and US, including the experience of US public libraries, is discussed. Manifestations of racism in the UK are described in relation to various institutions and legal provisions. The next section of the paper considers the employment of Black workers, both nationally and in the public libraries sector, with a need for cultural change being identified. This is followed by consideration of the Black community perspective, with reference to national issues and recent public libraries research. Various proposed solutions to tackle racism are discussed. It is concluded that whilst it is only Black communities and library workers that can eliminate racism, everyone, at all levels within public library authorities, has a responsibility to tackle racism (July, 2000).

Keywords:economic exclusion, human rights, public libraries, racial exclusion, racism, social class struggles, social exclusion, United Kingdom
Subjects:B. Information use and sociology of information. > BC. Information in society.
E. Publishing and legal issues. > EF. Censorship.
B. Information use and sociology of information. > BF. Information policy
D. Libraries as physical collections. > DC. Public libraries.
ID Code:5475
Deposited By:Muela-Meza, Zapopan Martín
Deposited On:23 January 2006
Alternative Locations:http://www.seapn.org.uk/workingpapers/vol3wp13.rtf
All fields:Show all fields

Ali, Rushanara (2000), Involving Black and ethnic minorities in decision making. Seminar hosted by the London Borough of Camden at the British Library on 19th January 2000. London: IPPR.

Armstrong, Hilary(1999), Speech given at the Federation of Black Housing Organisation Conference. London. October 29, 1999.

ASLIB (1995), Review of the Public Library Service in England and Wales - Final Report for the Department of National Heritage. London: The Association of Library Information Management.

Baldwin, P. and Foot, J. (1998), No quality without equality. London: Local Government Management Board.

Best Value - a statement of objectives. Local Government Association. [includes the joint statement between local government and three principal local government trade unions (GMB, TGWU, and UNISON)].

Black, Alistair (2000), Skeleton in the cupboard: social class and the public library in Britain through 150 years. [Written for Library History, May 2000].

Black, Alistair (2000a), A touch of class. Library Association Record. 102(5)2ooo, pp. 274-275.

Black, Alistair and Muddiman, Dave (1997), Understanding community librarianship: the public library in post-modern Britain. Aldershot:Avebury.

Black & Ethnic Minority Workers Group (Hackney) (1994) Library Services for Black and Ethnic Minority Nationalities in the U.K. - A Report Prepared for the DNH Review of Public Libraries.

Black, Ian (2000), EU fights far right with laws on racism. The Guardian. May, 18. http://www.guardianunlimited.co.uk/Archive/Article/0,4273,4019399,00.html Accessed: May 21, 2000.

Black, Ian (2000a), Tories oppose EU anti-racism directive. The Guardian May 19. http://www.guardianunlimited.co.uk/Archive/Article/0,4273,4019716,00.html Accessed: May 21, 2000.

Blair, Tony (1997) Labour conference speech. Quoted in Travis, A and Rowan, David (1997) A beacon burning darkly. [Analysis: Ethnic equality] The Guardian October 2, 1997:17.

Bowling, Ben (1999), Facing the ugly facts. The Guardian. February 17, 2000.

British police: Racists to the core (1998) Fight Racism Fight Imperialism 145, October/November 1998.

Brown, Matthew (2000), Seeking equality in a diverse world. Connections (London) Spring 2000, pp. 7-13.

Burrell, I (1998) The Independent. October 16, 1998.

Burton, C, Greenhalgh, L and Worpole, K (1996) London: Library City; the public library service in London: a strategic review (Commissioned by the Department of National Heritage). London: Comedia.

Campbell, B. (1998) Thoroughly modern Margaret. The Guardian November 12: 5.

Case Studies and Comments (1999). Anonymous comments about experiences of racism in libraries from 9 Black librarians. Circulated at the Library Association Conference “Institutional Racism; stamping it out in libraries”. Library Association, 12 November 1999.

Campaign Against Racism and Fascism (2000), Wasting the Macpherson opportunity. (CARF Features 53, December 1999/January 2000). http://www.carf.demon.co.uk/feat33.html Accessed: 24 April, 2000.

Chideya, Farai (1999) The Color of Our Future [Review from http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0688165303/ref=ad_bs1] Accessed February 13, 1999.

Clough, E. & Quarmby, J. (1978) A public library service for ethnic minorities in Great Britain. London: Library Association.

Coleman, S. Jr. On Combating Racism In Academic Librarianship . Forthcoming article in Information For Social Change (June, 2000).

Commission for Racial Equality (CRE) (n.d.), Code of Practice; Race relations. London:CRE.

Commission for Racial Equality (CRE, 1995, revised 1998) A standard for racial equality for local government; Racial equality means quality; a standard for racial equality for local government in England and Wales. London:CRE.

Commission for Racial Equality (CRE, 1999), The Stephen Lawrence Inquiry; implications for racial enquiry. London:CRE.

Compact BME! (2000) c/o NCVO, Tel. 020 7520 2454. E-mail contact: paul.barasi@ncvo-vol.org.uk.

Coysh, Daniel (2000), Justice, equality, respect. Morning Star May 20, p.7.

Cunningham, Marie (1996) Speech at the Open meeting for Black and Ethnic Minority Staff, Library Association, 17 April.

Castro, Fidel (2000) Quoted in Wilkinson, Stephen The aesthetics of Cuba’s revolution. Morning Star. March 24, 2000 p. 9.

DCMS (2000), Comprehensive and efficient – standards for modern public libraries: a consultation paper. London:Department for Culture, Media and Sport.

DETR (1998), Modern local government: In touch with the people. Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions.

DfEE (1999), Jobs for All. Nottingham: National Strategy for Neighbourhood Renewal (Report of the Policy Action Team 1).

DTI (2000), Closing the digital divide: information and communication technologies in deprived areas. (Report of the Policy Action Team 15).

Durrani, Shiraz (1993) The facts behind the Three Continents Liberation Collection. Hackney Libraries News No. 9, 7-9.

Durrani, Shiraz (1993) Contents and Relevance of Radio 4. Letter to the Controller, Radio 4.

Durrani, Shiraz (1996) Community Outreach and BME Services; A Report prepared for the Library Review, Hackney Libraries.

Durrani, S, Pateman, J, and Durrani, N (1999) The Black and Minority Ethnic Stock Group (BSG) in Hackney Libraries. Library Review 48 (1).

Durrani, Shiraz (1999) The educational role of public libraries in combating racism and xenophobia. Paper presented at the Second European Conference: Equality in Education: Towards the next millennium: Collaborating to combat racism and xenophobia across Europe. Verona, Italy 17-19 May 1999.

Durrani, Shiraz (1999a), Returning a stare; people's struggles for political and social inclusion. Social exclusion, an international perspective, Part 2: (Public Library Policy and Social Exclusion Working Papers, Working Paper Number 6), Leeds: Department of Information Management, Leeds Metropolitan University. To be published in Progressive Librarian.

Durrani, Shiraz (1999b) Black communities and information workers in search of social justice. New Library World Vol. 100 (1151) 1999. pp. 265-278.

Durrani, Shiraz (1999c) Libraries for all - A tool for change? A review of Libraries for All: Social Inclusion in Public Libraries; Policy Guidance for Local Authorities in England. October 1999. DCMS.

Durrani, Shiraz (2000) Black perspective on history of libraries; a review article. New Library World 101 (1155) April 2000. Reviews: Untold Stories; Civil Rights, Libraries, and Black Librarianship. Tucker, John Mark (Editor). Graduate School of Library and Information Science, University of Illinois. Champaign, IL, USA. 1998. 210pp. ISBN 0-87845-104-8.

Durrani, Shiraz (2000a) Memorandum submitted by Shiraz Durrani, Principal Librarian, London Borough of Merton. Public Libraries. Culture, Media and Sport Committee. Session 1999-2000. Sixth Report. London: the Stationery Office. Appendix 5, pp. 112-114.

Durrani, Shiraz (2000b) Combat racial exclusion. Paper presented at the Conference, Everybody Welcome? The role of libraries in a socially inclusive society. Thursday 16th March 2000, Council Chamber, Shirehall, Shrewsbury. Shropshire Library Service. Link-up 12(1) March 2000, pp. 15-23.

Durrani, Shiraz (2000c) Stop talking, start doing! Review article. Library Management. 21(8) 2000.

Durrani, Shiraz and Joyce, Paul (2000) Equality: A Service Development Approach. Research Note. Library Management. Research Note. 21(8) 2000.

Dyke, Greg (2000), The BBC: Leading Cultural Change For A Rich And Diverse UK. A Speech by BBC Director-General, at the Race in the Media Awards organised by the Commission for Racial Equality, 7 April 2000. http://www.bbc.co.uk/info/news/news232.htm. Accessed: 09 April 2000.

Elliott, Pirkko (1986) Ethnic minorities and public libraries: self-help and opportunities for co-operation. Library Management. 7(4).

Equalities Performance Indicators (Draft) (1996), Local Government Management Board.

Fairclough, Patricia (1999), Institutional racism – library. Presentation at the Library Association Conference, Black Contribution to Librarianship. November 12, 1999. London: LA.

Fekete, Liz (1999) Popular racism in corporate Europe. Race & Class 40(2/3) pp. 189-197.

Hackney Library Services. Black and Ethnic Minority Workers Group (1994) Library services for Black and ethnic minority nationalities in the U.K. - A Report prepared for the Department of National Heritage Review of Public Libraries.

Hall, Stuart (2000), From Scarman to Lawrence. Connections. Spring 2000.

Halpin, Anita (2000), The new fight for union democracy. Morning Star. March 10, 2000.

Hendry, Joe (2000), Here comes the sun. Library Association Record. 102(5) pp.272-3.

House of Commons, Culture, Media and Sport Committee (2000), Sixth Report: Public Libraries.

John, Gus (1995) Equality and Entitlement. Talk given by Gus John, Director, Directorate of Education and Leisure Services to Library Staff at Stamford Hill Library on Thursday February 23, 1995. (from notes made by the present author).

John, Gus (1999) Talk given at the Conference The Significance Of The Stephen Lawrence Inquiry For Public Libraries. London and Home Counties Branch: The Library Association in association with the Association of London Chief Librarians (ALCL). Executive Briefing: 28 June 1999.

Joyce, Paul, Durrani, Shiraz and Pateman, John (2000), Innovation in library services – working for social inclusion. Submitted to Public Library Journal, April 2000.

Khan, Ayub (1999) How far have we come, in this multicultural society? Library Association Record 101(2): 111.

Khan, Ayub (2000) Stamping out institutional racism. Library Association Record 102(1) pp. 38-39.

Kogbara, Donu (1998) “I’m quitting because of racism”. Race in the Media supplement in The Independent, December 1, 1998. p.15.

Kundnani, Arun (2000), ‘Stumbling on’: race, class and England. Race and Class. 41(4)pp. 1-18.

LA Corporate Plan (Draft, 2000). London:The Library Association. April 2000.

Library and Information Commission (2000), Libraries: the essence of inclusion. Policy Document. http://www.lic.gov.uk/ Accessed 24 April, 2000.

Library Association Equal Opportunities Information Pack. Includes (1) Public Library services for Britain’s multicultural society (nd); (2) Recruitment and Equal Opportunities (1996); (3) Recruitment and training of library and information staff from cultural minorities (1994).

Libraries for All: Social Inclusion in Public Libraries; Policy Guidance for Local Authorities in England (1999) London. DCMS. [PP267].

Local Government Association (1999) The Stephen Lawrence Inquiry and Home Secretary’s Action Plan; initial guidance for local authorities. Produced by the Local Government Association, the Employers’ Organisation and the Improvement and Development Agency.

Local Government Information Unit (1998) Best Value and Equal Opportunities. By Chelliah, R. Local Government Information Unit. [Spotlight on Best Value, 3].

Local Government Management Board Involving the public. Chapter 4: Equality of access.

Local Government Management Board (1996) “Evening the odds”; research into management development for Black and other minority ethnic managers. Executive Summary.

Local Government Management Board (1997) Equalities Performance Indicators (Draft).

Local Government Management Board (1998) “Evening the odds; research into management development for Black and other minority ethnic managers. Main Report.

Local Government Management Board (1998a) No quality without equality - best value and equalities. By: Baldwin, Pam and Foot, Jane.

Local Government Management Board. (1998b) Equality control.

Malik, H. (1998) A practical guide to equal opportunities, Cheltenham, Stanley Thornes (Publishers).

Mansfield, Mike (1999), After MacPherson. Red Pepper. April 1999. www.redpepper.org.uk Accessed June 12, 1999.

Mansfield, Mike (2000), The Legacy of Lawrence. Red Pepper, March 2000. www.redpepper.org.uk Accessed May 14, 2000.

Marks, K (1998), Trying to clarify the linguistic confusion. The Independent. October 16, 1998:8.

Matarasso, F. (1998), Learning development; an introduction to the social impact of public libraries. London: Comedia.

McKee, Bob (2000) Letter to LA membership, April 2000.

Medical schools “biased” against ethnic students. The Guardian. October 16:7.

Moodley, Ronnie (1999) BME associations need to fight institutionalised racism. Black Housing. No. 108 (October-November) p.4.

Muddiman, Dave (1999), Public libraries and social exclusion: the historical legacy. (Public Library Policy and Social Exclusion Working Paper 2). Leeds:Leeds Metropolitan University.

Myth of a golden age. The Library Association Record. 99(5):256.

Ngugi wa Thiong’o (1993), Moving the centre; the struggle for cultural freedoms. London: James Currey.

Naidoo, Seb (1999) Root and Branch. Red Pepper. February, 1999. www.redpepper.org.uk Accessed June 12, 1999.

Neely, T and Abif, K (1996) In our own voices; the changing face of librarianship. Lanham, Md. Scarescrow.

Ngugi wa Thiong’o (1993), Moving the centre; the struggle for cultural freedoms. London: James Currey.

Olden, Anthony, Tseng, C-P., Mcharazo, A. A. S. (1996): Service for All? A Review of the published literature on Black and ethnic minority/multicultural provision by public libraries in the United Kingdom (1996) Boston Spa, Wetherby, West Yorkshire: British Library Research & Development Department, 39pp. R & D. Report 6204.

Open to All? The Public Library and Social Exclusion (2000), Report of the "Public Library Policy and Social Exclusion". Volume 1: Overview and Conclusions (Draft), June 2000. Leeds: School of Information Management, Leeds Metropolitan University.

Our fight for equality. Race in the Media supplement in The Independent, December 1, 1998. p.15.

Pallister, D (1998) When sorry is not enough. The Guardian October 2, 1998.

Patel, Pragna (1999) After MacPherson. Red pepper. April 1999. www.redpepper.org.uk Accessed: 12 June, 1999.

Pateman, J. (1998) Planning to tackle poverty. Library Association Record. 100(9):472.

Pateman, J. (1999) The state, communities and public libraries: their role in tackling social exclusion. Social exclusion, an international perspective, Part 1: (Public Library Policy and Social Exclusion Working Papers, Working Paper Number 6), Leeds: Department of Information Management, Leeds Metropolitan University.

Pateman, John (1999a) Public Libraries and social class. (Public Library Policy and Social Exclusion Working Paper 3). Leeds: Department of Information Management, Leeds Metropolitan University.

Pateman, John (2000) Working together to tackle social exclusion. Assignation January, 2000.

Perera, Suvendrini (1998/99) The level playing field: Hansonism, globalisation, racism. Race & Class 40(2/3) pp. 199-208.

Prime, E. (1998) High Profile: Eugenie Prime. SepiaNews; Libraries, Community & Technology (New York) Spring 1998.

Quality Leaders Project for Black Library & Information Workers - Research Findings, Feasibility Study, and Proposals. Report to Library & Information Commission (2000) Management Research Centre. University of North London.

Racial Discrimination; a guide to the Race Relations Act 1976 (1977). Home Office.

Racism in the Met (1998) The Guardian October 2, p. 25. (Leader comment).

Raven, D. (1998) Multicultural services. Library Association Record. 100(9): 466-7.

Reese, Gregory L and Hawkins, Ernestine L (1999) Stop Talking, Start Doing! Attracting people of color to the library profession. Chicago. American Library Association. xix, pp.136. ISBN 0-8389-0762-8. (For a review article based on the book, see Durrani, S 2000c).

Roach, Patrick and Morrison, M (1998), Public libraries, ethnic diversity and citizenship. (British Library Research and Innovation Report 76). Coventry: CEDAR, University of Warwick.

Roots of racism (1982). London. Institute of Race Relations.

Russell, Ben (1999) Black expulsions blamed on racism. The Independent June 4, p.12.

Russell, Ben and Laurence, Jeremy (1998) Racism found in selection of young doctors. The Independent October 16, p.8.

Singh, Gurbux (2000), Quoted in CRE harangues inflammatory language. Morning Star April 15, 2000, p.4.

Sivanandan, Ambalavaner(2000) The Latest from London Live http://www.bbc.co.uk/londonlive/news/racism_sivanandan_240200.shtml Accessed: 24 April, 2000.

Social Exclusion Unit Leaflet (2000) London: Cabinet Office. http://www.cabinet-office.gov.uk/seu/ Accessed: 24 April, 2000.

Social Exclusion Unit. (1998), Bringing Britain together: a national strategy for neighbourhood renewal. Cm 4045.

Social Exclusion Unit (2000), Minority Ethnic issues in social exclusion and neighbourhood renewal; a guide of the work of the Social Exclusion Unit and the Policy Action Teams so far. CABI 00-5346/0006/D40.

Social Exclusion Unit (2000), National Strategy for Neighbourhood renewal: a framework for consultation. Report by the Social Exclusion Unit. Crown copyright 2000.

Social Exclusion Unit (2000), Minority Ethnic Issues in Social Exclusion and Neighbourhood Renewal; A guide to the work of the SEU and the Policy Action Teams so far.

Stephen Lawrence Inquiry: Report of an inquiry by Sir William Macpherson of Cluny (1999). The Home Office. Cm 4252-1.

Stevenson, Brian (1999) Draft standards and guidelines for public libraries in England. Audit commission. LIB-CNET - Online consultation on Libraries for All.

Straw, Jack (2000), Take race out of asylum. The Observer April 23, 2000, p.28.

Thomas, R [1998]: The big trade off. Prospect, Guardian Taster. p.6.

Time to make a difference. Library Association Record 102(5) May 2000, p. 246.

Timms, M. (1999) Black and Asian services worthy of the millennium. Library Association Record. 101(2): 85.

Travis, Alan (1999) Stephen Lawrence’s legacy: confronting racist Britain. The Guardian February 25, p.1.

Travis, Alan (2000) Man with a mission [Gurbux Singh]. The Guardian (Society) March 22, 2000, pp. 2-3.

Travis, Alan and Rowan, David (1998). A Beacon Burning Darkly. The Guardian.

Tucker, John Mark (Editor). 1998. Untold Stories; Civil Rights, Libraries, and Black Librarianship. Graduate School of Library and Information Science, University of Illinois. Champaign, IL, USA. 210pp. ISBN 0-87845-104-8. (For a review article based on the book, see Durrani, S 2000.)

TUC (Reprinted 1989). Tackling Racism; a TUC workbook. London.

TUC (1996) United against racism in Europe; tackling racism and xenophobia in Europe – a TUC handbook for shop stewards. London.

TUC (1998) Union Action for race equality; a negotiators’ guide. London, Labour Research Department, TUC.

TUC (2000) Qualifying for racism; how racism is increasingly blighting career prospects. ESAD, Jan 2000.

Vincent, John (1986), An introduction to community librarianship. London: Association of Assistant Librarians.

Watt, Nicholas (2000), Minister admits Home Office is still racist after staff claim bias. The Guardian April 8, 2000.

Wells, Matt (2000) BBC ‘tries to bury’ inquiry on equality. The Guardian April, 28, 2000, p. 7.

Williams, Helen (1999)Tackling Racism. Bulletin.doc No.1. (London, National Housing Federation).

Williams, Patricia J. (1997), The Genealogy of race. The 1997 Reith Lecture, No. 5. London: BBC. [Transcript, p.7].

Wintour, Patrick (2000), Whitehall mandarins ‘balking’ Black staff. The Guardian April 15, 2000, p.7.

What’s New; LARRIE’s Quarterly Update. No. 16 (p.2); No 17 (2000). Details about Local Authorities Race Relations Information Exchange can be found at www.lg-employers.gov.uk/equal-info.html from where racial equality action plans and special reports can be downloaded.

Williams, Patricia J. (1997) The genealogy of race…towards a theory of grace. The 1977 Reith Lectures. Broadcast on BBC Radio 4. Quoted from the transcript: No. 1: The Emperor's New Clothes, 25th February 1999. No. 5: An ordinary brilliance: parting the waters, closing the wounds..

Williams, Rhys (1998). In plain Black and white. Race in the Media supplement in The Independent, December 1, 1998. P.15

Younge, Gary (2000) Paying up. The Guardian (Jan. 8) p. 20.

Archive Staff Only: edit this record

   home   |   about   |   search   |   browse   |   register   |   registered users area   |   help   |   FAQ   |   JITA   

Send comments and questions to      |     E-LIS is hosted by AEPIC at CILEA      |     Powered by GNU Eprints software